Sunday, November 25, 2012

HSBC chairman urges bankers to swear an oath

The Telegraph reports that the HSBC chairman is urging bankers to swear an oath similar to that sworn by doctors in a bid to restore trust in banks and bankers.

Before taking the oath, every bank needs to begin providing ultra transparency and disclosing on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

Ultra transparency is needed not only because this form of sunshine that is the best disinfectant, but because it is the foundation of the bankers pledge to engage in an honest, fair manner with all of their clients, customers and counter-parties.

Everyone knows that a bank and its bankers that are not willing to provide ultra transparency are hiding something and should never be trusted.

So when is HSBC going to start providing ultra transparency?

Douglas Flint, the chairman of HSBC, is pushing for bankers to take an oath similar to that sworn by doctors as part of radical plans to overhaul the way the profession is viewed in the wake of the financial crisis and successive banking scandals. 
He is calling for the oath to be administered by an independent body designed to police the banking industry and is understood to have discussed the prospect with his counterparts at the UK’s other big banks....
With ultra transparency, all market participants could police the banking industry.  We have already seen with the financial crisis that regulators are not up to the task.
Mr Flint, the bank’s finance director for 15 years before being elevated to chairman in 2011, is working with the British Bankers Association (BBA) on the idea....
The very same British Bankers Association that brought us the opaque mechanism for setting Libor that allowed the banks to manipulate the rate for their own profit behind a veil of opacity.
The first of eight principles sets out the need “to act honestly and fairly at all times when dealing with clients, customers and counter-parties”.
In order to abide by this first principle, the bank must provide ultra transparency.  Without this information, it is impossible for clients, customers and counter-parties to know if the bank and its bankers are acting honestly and fairly.

Tax havens: an example of banks fighting to retain opacity in the financial system

In an interesting article, the Guardian looks at the fight to bring transparency to tax havens so that countries can know if their citizens are paying what they owe in taxes.

Clearly, this is a major issue given the amount of sovereign debt outstanding.

It is another example of why transparency must be brought to all the opaque, corners of the financial system.

Regular readers will not be surprised to learn that leading the fight to block transparency are the banks.

The world is seeing the first stirrings of an emerging new architecture of global transparency in taxation which could, if pushed forwards, help governments for the first time raise serious revenues from the estimated $21-32 trillion sitting offshore. 
Switzerland, in alliance with the tax havens of Luxembourg, Austria and Britain, is leading the charge to derail it.
And who in these countries would be leading the charge to derail transparency?  Why the banks whose private client business model is based on helping their clients defer paying taxes.
The battle now under way hinges on a powerful transparency principle called automatic information exchange. According to this, governments routinely tell each other about the cross-border assets and income of one another's citizens so they can tax them appropriately. 
This is the gold standard of transparency and the basis for a multilateral European scheme, the European Savings Tax Directive, which includes 42 European and other countries. This multilateral scheme is riddled with loopholes, but it is already up and running. Amendments to plug those loopholes are being prepared. 
A second pillar of the emerging architecture is run by the OECD, a club of rich countries that contains several tax havens (including Britain, which partly controls a number of major tax havens, such as the Cayman Islands, the British Virgin Islands and Jersey). 
The OECD scheme runs on a ridiculously weak transparency principle: information exchange on request. Here, you cannot make blanket information requests to a tax haven: you must ask, on a case-by-case basis. That means you effectively have to know the information you are looking for – before you ask for it. Precious little information flows through these narrow pipes....
It is no surprise that the banks oppose automatic information exchange in favor of information exchange on request.

This is yet another example of the veil of opacity allowing misbehavior to occur.  This time the party potentially engaging in misbehavior by not paying their taxes is the client.  However, they are aided and abetted in this by the bankers.
In August last year, Switzerland threw a huge spanner into the works. It signed bilateral tax deals – "Rubik agreements" – with Germany and Britain, based on a very different principle: wealthy people with Swiss accounts can preserve their secrecy and, instead, merely pay a one-off, withholding tax on assets, and a bit of future income. "Trust us," say Swiss bankers – who have centuries of form helping the world's wealthy get around the rules of civilised society.... 
The Rubik project is a Swiss swindle – and a humiliation for this government. If successful it would, in the words of Professor Itai Grinberg of Georgetown University, "stifle the emergence of multilateral automatic information exchange". 
The Swiss Bankers' Association, which designed Rubik, has explicitly admitted that its original purpose was "to prevent" automatic information exchange: in other words, to kill the European Savings Tax Directive. In particular, crucial and powerful amendments to plug the directive's loopholes are now held up because Luxembourg says it won't accept them if Germany and Britain (and now the tax haven of Austria, which has signed its own Rubik deal) get special bilateral treatment from Switzerland. 
This obstructionism was the plan all along. ....
Thankfully, Germany's Bundesrat is widely expected to throw its Rubik deal out in a vote on Friday. ...  A top Green party official called it "a slap in the face for all honest taxpayers"; and the head of the centre-left Social Democratic party, has accused Swiss banks of engaging in "organised crime". 
If Germany rejects the deal, as seems likely, Austria will be easily dealt with, leaving Britain alone as the last big obstacle to progress in the greatest transparency project the world has seen.

Saturday, November 24, 2012

European Parliament call for transparency and the creation of the "Mother of all financial databases"

In studying how to balance the risks and benefits of shadow banking, the European Parliament concludes this is best done by enhancing transparency and creating the "Mother of all financial databases".

From a European Parliament press release,

Better prudential oversight is needed to reduce shadow banking's systemic risks, without stifling its benefits to the economy, say MEPs in a resolution voted on Tuesday. 
Shadow banking institutions account for up to 30% of the global financial system, worth over €50 trillion in 2011. In good times, they provide credit to people or entities that otherwise cannot get it and so fund the real economy. But if they make bad investments they have no protection, because they do not hold deposits and have no access to central bank liquidity. 
Risks to regular banks
Shadow banks do not exist on their own. They are interconnected with regular banks, which often use them to get round capital and accounting rules. If they collapse, they can cause a domino effect across other financial institutions and borders, bringing down regular banks and ultimately harming taxpayers across the EU who are obliged to come to the rescue. 
Safeguard alternative funding
MEPs say that shadow banking should be better monitored and supervised, so as to reduce the systemic risks they pose without cutting of the benefits that they provided to the real economy. 
Prudential oversight should reduce the systemic risks that shadow banking may pose due to the lack of data on financial flows and interconnections and the highly complex nature of its financial products....
Identify systemic risks
MEPs also suggest ways to reduce identified systemic risks, such as extending capital requirements to all unregulated entities, imposing limits on the complexity of  financial products or considering whether shadow banking entities linked to a bank should be included in the bank's balance sheet. 
Finally, MEPs call on the Commission to adopt a consistent approach to collecting data centrally, with a view to mapping all financial service transactions in real time so as to capture the riskiest deals.
The first step in mapping financial flows is to collect the data on each financial institution's exposures.  Doing this requires that the financial institutions provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

This data should be collected and made available to all market participants through the "Mother of all financial databases".

King vs Osborne: a tussle over meaningless bank capital requirements

Against the backdrop of EU banks asking for a one year delay in the introduction of Basel III in light of the US not implementing Basel III in 2013, we have the spectacle of the Bank of England's Mervyn King fighting with UK Chancellor George Osborne over leverage on UK bank balance sheets.

Regular readers know that bank capital and any ratio involving bank capital is meaningless.

The OECD observed that bank capital is meaningless given the existence of regulatory forbearance that allows banks to engage in 'extend and pretend' with bad debt and the suspension of mark-to-market accounting.  Both directly manipulate bank book capital levels by overstating exactly how much book capital there is.

Capital ratios are an example of the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight that are substituted for transparency and market discipline.

The financial crisis showed that this substitution contributes to financial instability and makes the financial system prone to failure.

Regular readers know that what is needed is to require the banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.  With this information, market participants can independently assess the risk of each bank and calculate capital ratios if they want to as part of this assessment.
Indeed, the more important clash is King v Osborne on the vital issue of the degree of leverage on UK banks' balance sheets. 
Vickers' panel was crystal clear: leverage should be capped at 25 times capital. But the chancellor has watered down that proposal, saying the government is happy to tolerate 33 times. 
To most outsiders, it looks as if Osborne has been swayed by the lobbying of the likes of Santander UK, which argues that a mortgage-dominated bank would be constricted by Vickers' harder limits. 
Of course the government is swayed by the lobbying of the industry.  There is no surprise here.

What is left unsaid is that both King and Osborne are swayed by the lobbying.  In particular, both of them are spending time arguing about a meaningless capital ratio when what is needed is to restore transparency to the banking system.
Vickers was unhappy about the watering-down and King sounds furious. 
The governor gave a blistering defence of the more conservative approach. International standards for calculating risk-weighted assets are too inflexible; risk weights move over time; and in major crises risks tend to interact. For those reasons, pure leverage ratios have proved the best guide to the strength of a bank in a crisis. 
As King pointed out, Northern Rock, while fully up-to-date with the Basel banking committee's finely tuned risk calculations, was still operating at 80 times leverage before its collapse. 
The argument over the right amount of leverage is nonsense.

The only relevant issue is how much risk the banks are taking so that market participants can adjust their exposure to each bank based on the risk of each bank and the market participant's capacity to absorb losses given this risk.
Setting sensible leverage ratios should therefore be at the top of the reform agenda. It's more important than the detail of which activities should lie, or be required to lie, within a ring-fenced bank.
Actually, what should be at the top of the reform agenda is requiring transparency.
If King, Vickers (and Tucker?) think 25 times is high enough and that Osborne is being too racy, that's a major concern. Let's hope the commission, which seems to be in a mischievous mood, kicks up a storm about leverage.
I am hoping the commission kicks up a storm about transparency which is what truly matters and is the only sensible reform.

UK financial institution calls for full deposit insurance

Nationwide Building Society, a UK financial institution, answered the question of why was there a run on Northern Rock while calling for full deposit insurance.

As reported by the Telegraph, Nationwide would like full deposit insurance for all financial institutions so as to eliminate the confusion that triggered the run on Northern Rock.

The reason for the run was that Northern Rock depositors knew that their deposits were guaranteed up to a certain level, but were confused over what this level was.

Remember, with deposit insurance, depositors don't care about the performance of the bank.  They only care they can get their money back.
Nationwide Building Society has been lobbying for clearer and more comprehensive protection for depositors for over a year now, and is stepping up efforts ahead of publication of the new Financial Services Bill. 
Under current arrangements, savings are only insured up to a maximum of £85,000 per person per bank or building society. Above that, savers would face losses if the company failed. 
However, Graham Beale, Nationwide’s chief executive, told The Daily Telegraph: “[Protection] should apply to all deposits, not just those less than £85,000.” 
In 2007, confusion over the level of protection sparked the run that brought down Northern Rock, as depositors queued to withdraw their money until the Chancellor promised every penny would be backed by the taxpayer. 
Changes are now being made to the law to enshrine “depositor preference”, which will put insured deposits ahead of other bondholders in the creditor hierarchy to guarantee savers get £85,000 back within days of a bank’s collapse. 
However, Nationwide, the UK’s second largest savings provider with £125bn in deposits, wants the law extended to cover all retail savings to avoid confusion. “The consumer message of full depositor preference is much more powerful and comprehensible,” Mr Beale said.
 Full depositor protection is now implicit based on the government's action in 2007.
The mutual is backed by the Building Societies Association but its position sets it against the banking industry, which does not even back “depositor preference” for the first £85,000. 
Banks claim the £85,000 is protected by the industry insurance scheme so there is no need for a complex legal change that puts other creditors more at risk and may consequently push up banks’ costs. 
“Depositor preference gives customers no added protection and increases substantially the losses of other creditors,” the British Bankers’ Association said in its Parliamentary submission.
It is not surprising that UK banks do not want depositors to have preference.  They know that it is really the taxpayer that is guaranteeing the deposits.

For example, in the US, the FDIC has unlimited ability to draw from the US Treasury to cover losses on its deposit guarantee.

The lack of preference increases the potential for loss on the deposits with the benefit accruing to the other creditors and therefore to the bankers in terms of cheaper funding.  That is why in the US deposit insurance scheme the FDIC has preference over other creditors.

Friday, November 23, 2012

Two Columbia University economists think that raising rates is cure for economic slump

As reported by Bloomberg, two Columbia University economists have adopted your humble blogger's suggestion that raising interest rates will help to cure the economic slump.

Regular readers have seen numerous posts over the last couple of years discussing Walter Bagehot and his rule that central banks never lower rates below 2%.

Mr. Bagehot, the father of modern central banking, laid out this rule in the 1870s.  He did this in full knowledge of Mark Twain's famous observation about being more concerned about the return of his capital than the return on his capital.

Mr. Bagehot understood that as rates drop below 2% they create their own economic headwinds including that savers start pursuing Mark Twain's observation.

The solution to weak economic growth may be higher interest rates. 
That seemingly paradoxical remedy can apply if the cause of the slump is a confidence shock that cheap borrowing costs are failing to reverse, two Columbia University economists said in a report published this week. 
In such a situation, ultra-easy monetary policy risks making fears of deflation a self- fulfilling prophecy as spenders sit tight. 
If low interest rates can’t motivate jittery consumers, then the answer may be the opposite: an increase in borrowing costs. Such a shift “can boost inflationary expectations and therefore foster employment,” said Stephanie Schmitt-Grohe and Martin Uribe in the study published Nov. 19 by the National Bureau of Economic Research in Cambridge, Mass.
“By its effect on real wages, future inflation stimulates employment, thereby lifting the economy out of the slump,” they said. 
The academics said sagging confidence among households and companies has played a part in the recent economic slowdown. Evidence from the U.S. as well as Japan during the last two decades “seems to suggest that zero nominal interest rates are not doing much to push inflation higher.”
At the moment, the Federal Reserve pledges to keep its benchmark interest rate near zero through mid-2015.
While I am not an economist, I suspect that the transmission mechanism for economic improvement from higher interest rates is that savers no longer have to offset the lack of return on their savings through more savings, but can instead use this money for consumption.

Banking can be made honest and fail-safe

In case no one has noticed, everyone who has testified before the Parliament's Commission on Banking Standards has concluded that the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight will neither make banks honest nor fail-safe.

This list of high-powered witnesses includes the UK Chancellor, George Osborne, the Governor of the Bank of England, Sir Mervyn King, a leading contender as next Governor of the BoE, Paul Tucker and former Fed Chairman Paul Volcker.

As an example of why the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight will neither make banks honest nor fail-safe, each of them looked at the flaws in the proposals to separate investment and retail banking using the Volcker Rule, ring-fencing or complete separation.

Your humble blogger was thrilled that all of these distinguished individuals confirmed what I have been saying all along about the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight is not an effective substitute for transparency and market discipline.

Everyone knows that requiring the banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details would make the banks honest.

Sunshine is the best disinfectant.

Everyone also knows that transparency makes the banks fail-safe.

With access to the information disclosed through ultra transparency, market participants can independently assess the risk of each bank.  With this risk assessment, market participants can adjust the amount of their exposure to each bank to what they can afford to lose given the risk of each bank.

As a result, a bank is both subject to market discipline to restrain its risk taking and, if it ignores this restraint, can fail without fear of financial contagion.

Hopefully, the commission members will see that substituting the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight for transparency and market discipline doesn't work.  And they will conclude that reform needs to focus on bringing transparency to all the opaque corners of the financial system.

Thursday, November 22, 2012

BoE's Paul Tucker: splitting retail and investment banking won't make system safe

Speaking to the parliamentary commission on banking standards, the Bank of England's Paul Tucker observed that splitting retail and investment banking won't make the system safer.

His reason for making this statement is that he thinks that investment banks are fully capable of blowing up the financial system.

Combine this with the historic fact that retail banks are fully capable of blowing themselves up (see: US Savings & Loan for example) and it is clear that pursuing regulations that would create a ring-fence or full separation is unproductive.

What is needed is reform that would actually make the financial system safer and financial crises far less likely to occur.

Regular readers know that there is only one reform that achieves this goal:  bring transparency to all the opaque corners of the financial system.

That this works can be easily seen by the simple fact that

  • the parts of the financial system characterized by opacity, including complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight, were the parts that ceased functioning and haven't resumed functioning since the start of the financial crisis.
  • the parts of the financial system characterized by transparency and market discipline have continued to function throughout the financial crisis.
As reported by the Guardian,
Paul Tucker, the frontrunner to become the next governor of the Bank of England, has told MPs he does not want to see the full separation of retail and investment banks. 
Speaking to a parliamentary committee on banking standards, Tucker warned that even if the separation of banks was forced by law, the economy would still be at risk of being "blown up" by non-retail banks and other financial institutions.
Tucker said: "The thing that has worried me most about this debate from the beginning ... is that people fall into thinking, 'if only we could make retail banking safe, the financial system will be safe', and frankly I think that is nonsense. I think the financial system and the economy will be capable of being blown up by vast wholesale dealers and non-banks."...
Please re-read Mr. Tucker's comments as he effectively explains why transparency is the solution that works rather than the combination of complex rules/regulation and regulatory oversight.

With transparency, nobody assumes that the financial system is or will be safe.  Rather, all market participants know that they still have the obligation to independently assess the risk of each of their exposures and to not have a larger exposure than they can afford to lose given the risk.

That this occurs is not surprising as the FDR Framework combines the philosophy of disclosure with the principle of caveat emptor (buyer beware).
Clarity, he said, was crucial to avoid banks lobbying the regulator. "For the regulator to be effective, it has to be able to use judgment. But if judgment ends up simply as a negotiation between the regulator and the regulated bank, there's only one winner in that and I think that will be a very bad outcome."
While Mr. Tucker was talking about ring-fencing, I think his comment is applicable to the entire idea of  substituting the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight for transparency and market discipline.

The combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight is doomed to failure as it ultimately ends up as a negotiation between the regulator (who can be pressured by politicians) and the regulated banks that the regulated banks will win.

Ironically, transparency is all about bringing clarity and avoiding having banks lobbying the regulator.

Take ultra transparency for example.  Under ultra transparency, banks are required to disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.  This disclosure brings clarity to all market participants on the risks each bank is taking.

With ultra transparency it is no longer the regulator negotiating with the bank over the riskiness of the bank, but the regulator judging the riskiness of the bank using the analytical capabilities of the market (the regulator can ask other banks how risky they think each bank is for example).

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

George Osborne defends big banks as good for UK

In his testimony to Parliament, George Osborne not only defended the idea that big banks are good for UK society, but also expressed his wish that the UK had more big banks.

I am confident that Mr. Osborne's statement will generate a number of articles and posts saying:
  • Hope he gets his wish and that (fill in the country's name)'s largest banks will all move there so that (fill in the country's name)'s taxpayers will no longer have to bail them out; or
  • How could he have offered up that myth about the need for large banks when both the recent financial crisis and academic studies have debunked this idea and shown that banks never need to exceed $100 billion in size.
What I found more interesting is his defense of the big banks rested on the observation that other countries had them so therefore the UK should too.

The fact that other countries have these banks doesn't prove these banks are good for society.

As reported by the Telegraph,
Commission member Justin Welby, the Bishop of Durham and Archbishop of Canterbury in waiting, asked the Mr Osborne why he could not simply break up big banks altogether. 
Mr Osborne said he believed the survival of big banks was good for UK society. 
"If we aggressively broke up all of our big banks, I am not sure that, as a society, we would benefit form it," said the Chancellor. 
"There are still a lot of big banks operating in other countries. I think it is important for the UK that our largest private sector industry thrives, survives and grows, employing very large numbers of people across the UK. 
"I want Britain to be the home of big successful banks. I think it would be a real shame if we were saying to the likes of HSBC that they can't locate themselves in the UK. I think that would be a mistake for us as a country. 
"I think we have to strike the right balance. We want to be a home to successful financial services but we want those services to be safer."
Regular readers know that I don't think that politicians and regulators should get into figuring out how to break up the big banks.

It is far easier to break these banks up by simply requiring them to provide ultra transparency and let market discipline force them to break themselves up.

Under ultra transparency, banks would be required to disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.  With this information, market participants could independently assess the risk of each bank and adjust the price of their exposure to reflect this risk.

As riskier banks see their cost of funding increase, they will be under tremendous pressure to reduce their risk.  The easiest way to reduce risk is by getting out of the riskiest businesses.
Mr Osborne also warned the commission against attempting to rewrite the Bill so close to its passage through Parliament. 
"I don't think personally this is the right moment to tear up all the work that's been done over the last two years. That would inevitably delay things and I think we have got to a good place where broadly we have a consensus," he said. 
"You will be unpicking the work that John Vickers and his commissioners did. That work has been accepted, as far as I'm aware, by all the major political parties. We are now on the verge of getting on with it." 
Commission members bridled at the suggestion that Mr Osborne was seeking to limit their inquiry. 
Labour MP Pat McFadden told the Chancellor: "If you are worrying about the freedom and powers of the Commission, perhaps you should have thought about that before establishing it... 
"If you were sitting on this side of the table, you wouldn't take too kindly to a Chancellor saying 'I want you to look at that, but not to look at that'." 
Commission chairman Andrew Tyrie said the members did not find it "very convincing to be told that we should be wary of unpicking a consensus". 
"Just because something has achieved a consensus does not necessarily mean that it is right. It is our job to take a look at it," said Mr Tyrie....
Please re-read the highlighted text as this is exactly what I have been saying about the proposal to substitute the combination of complex rules/regulations and regulatory oversight for transparency and market discipline.
[Mr. Osborne] also said the draft Bill was imposing a lot of cost on banks and a full separation would be an even greater cost. 
"Exactly the same Members of Parliament who say we must screw the banks down are the same ones getting up and saying we have got to get the banks to lend," he said...
Mr. Osborne makes a compelling case for ending the pursuit of complex rules/regulations like ring-fencing.

It is very inexpensive to provide ultra transparency.

Equally importantly, providing ultra transparency does not impede a bank's ability to make a loan.
Mr Osborne said the primary purpose of the legislation was to ensure that, in a future crisis, a Chancellor is able to allow a bank to fail while protecting consumers, rather than being forced to bail it out, as his predecessor Alistair Darling was because of the "inadequate" legislation in place at the time of the 2007-8 banking crash. 
"Ultimately, what this is all about is so that the person doing my job – hopefully not on my watch – when faced at midnight with that decision 'Do you let this very large bank go bust?' has enough confidence to say 'I think we can let it go because the banking Bill has provided me with enough reassurance that we can continue to provide core services, that people can go to cashpoints and get their money out'," said Mr Osborne. 
"My predecessor, when he was faced with that decision, felt he was not confident that people would be able to get their money out of the cashpoint in the morning. 
"If, at the end of all this, the person doing my job is still not confident that people can get their cash out of the cashpoint even if they let the institution fail, then I think we as a Parliament will have failed."
One of the many benefits of requiring the banks to provide ultra transparency is that it ensures that a Chancellor can feel comfortable in the middle of the night allowing a bank to fail.

With ultra transparency, market participants know they will not be bailed out.  The reason they will not be bailed out is that they have access to the information they need to independently assess the risk of each bank and to adjust their exposure to each bank to what the market participant can afford to lose given the risk.

This permanently ends bailing out the banks for fear of financial contagion.

Regular readers also know that in a modern financial system there is no reason to ever bailout a bank.  Banks can continue to operate and support the real economy even when they have low or negative book capital levels because of the combination of deposit insurance and access to central bank funding.

With deposit insurance, the taxpayers become the silent equity partners of any bank with low or negative book capital levels.

Hence, until the financial regulators decide to shut down the bank, it can continue in operations.

Funding for lending and ongoing loan forbearance

Lest anyone forget that there is an unknown quantity of bad loans hidden on bank balance sheets, the Bank of England's report on how the Funding for Lending program is going reminds us.

As reported by the Guardian,

It does appear to be having an impact for customers looking for a mortgage. The Bank of England's closely-watched agents' report says: "Recent reductions in institutions' marginal funding costs appeared to be working through more quickly in the residential mortgage market than corporate lending." 
But the picture still looks for bleak for small businesses. "Some business lenders appeared still to be tightening terms," the agents said. Overdrafts were being restricted and banks demanding "additional personal guarantees" for credit. 
Not exactly what the government intended. 
And even in those instances where lenders are starting to offer loans at lower rates, the demand from small business to borrow money is low. 
The agents' report says that lenders are continuing to show a "significant degree of forbearance" to help businesses in financial difficulty. Helpful for businesses, but not reassuring for anyone worried about the potential bad loans being stored up on banks' balance sheets.