Wednesday, January 25, 2012

More on the Eurozone banks ongoing manipulation of their book capital

As the countdown to June 30, 2012 continues, Eurozone banks are reaching into their bag of tricks to reach the financial regulator's 9% Tier I capital ratio.

A NY Times Dealbook article has the latest update.

Regular readers know that this activity is load with downside risk (it is driving a credit crunch in the Eurozone) and little upside (the risk profiles of the banks are increasing as the banks shed good assets and other profitable business lines).

Financial institutions on the Continent have raised at least 40.7 billion euros, or $52.8 billion, in new capital as of the fourth quarter of last year, according to estimates by Citigroup. 
The effort is part of policymakers’ push to increase banks’ core Tier 1 ratios, a measure of a firm’s ability to weather financial shocks, to 9 percent by June. Banks must raise a combined 115 billion euros by the summer to meet that target. 
Activity over the next few weeks will add to the tally. Europe’s major banks report earnings in February, and Citigroup said it expected institutions to raise a further 24.6 billion euros through June 2012 through so-called retained earnings, a category that includes reductions in employee bonuses and cuts to overall bank lending....
While some of Europe’s largest financial institutions are likely to fill the capital gap by holding on to their profits, others will have to employ different strategies. 
So far, the most popular method for raising new money has been through so-called liability management exercises. 
Citigroup estimated European institutions had raised a combined 16 billion euros through the practice, which involves buying back, or exchanging, hybrid securities — investments that pay dividends like bonds, but can be converted into equity — at a discount from investors.
Accountancy rules allow financial institutions to book the difference between the original face value of the securities and the current discounted price as a profit toward their core Tier 1 equity. Raiffeisen of Austria, for example, has pocketed 1.3 billion euros toward its 2.1 billion euro target in this manner. The Italian bank Banco Popolare has raised a further 996 million euros. 
Adjustments to banks’ balance sheets have outpaced so-called rights offerings, which allow existing shareholders to buy new stock in a company at a discount. 
Authorities had expected many institutions to tap investors for new capital....
Many firms are relying on multiple strategies. Along with its rights offering, UniCredit is reorganizing its balance sheet. On Wednesday, the Italian lender said it would buy as much as 3 billion euros of hybrid securities at a discount of up to 50 percent. The move could raise up to 500 million euros toward the bank’s core Tier 1 ratio. UniCredit is also planning to issue up to 25 billion euros of covered bonds — debt securities that are backed by the bank’s own assets — to ease its financing problems, according to a filing with the Luxembourg Stock Exchange on Wednesday.
Other banks are shedding assets to meet the new requirements. 
Citigroup estimates European banks have disposed of operations worth almost 100 billion euros, as of the fourth quarter of 2011. That helped firms, including Banco Santander of Spain, to increase their capital reserves by a combined 6.6 billion euros over the period. 
“The list of asset sales is the longest I’ve seen in 10 years,” said Richard Thompson, a partner at accountancy firm PricewaterhouseCoopers in London. “Banks want to reshape their balance sheets to focus on specific territories or sectors.”

Mitt Romney appears to endorse key elements of blueprint to save financial system

Eliot Spitzer and Dylan Ratigan wrote an article that appeared in the Huffington Post (hat/tip MS) on Mitt Romney's State of the Union Challenge on the Mortgage Crisis.

Based on what Mitt Romney said, he too sees a need for banks to act as a safety valve between the excesses in the financial system and the real economy.  Specifically, he wants banks to realize the losses on their mortgages as a first step towards ending the ongoing mortgage debacle.
Finally, a presidential candidate came out and honestly addressed the biggest problem in our economy, the enormous debt overhang in our mortgage market. A few days ago, Mitt Romney was at a forum in Florida talking about foreclosures, and his comments were actually refreshingly honest about our housing and banking situation and the need for a debt write-down. 
We're just so overleveraged, so much debt in our society, and some of the institutions that hold it aren't willing to write it off and say they made a mistake, they loaned too much, we're overextended, write those down and start over. They keep on trying to harangue and pretend what they have on their books is still what it's worth. 
Mitt Romney was pointing out that the banks are carrying debt on their books at inflated values. When was the last serious politician to make that point, openly? There's more. 
In some cases, if the debt is not in something you can service, it's like you have to move on and start over away from those debts. It's helpful if you get an institution that's willing to work with you, but if you don't you have no other option. 
Romney is now saying that if you can't pay your debts and your lending institution won't work with you, walk away. Perhaps this isn't so surprising, though, as Romney is an expert in debt restructuring. This is actually just common business sense. 
And finally, he offered a real solution to the mortgage debt crisis.
The banks are scared to death, of course, because they think they're going to go out of business... They're afraid that if they write all these loans off, they're going to go broke. And so they're feeling the same thing you're feeling. They just want to pretend all of this is going to get paid someday so they don't have to write it off and potentially go out of business themselves." 
This is cascading throughout our system and in some respects government is trying to just hold things in place, hoping things get better... My own view is you recognize the distress, you take the loss and let people reset. Let people start over again, let the banks start over again. Those that are prudent will be able to restart, those that aren't will go out of business. This effort to try and exact the burden of their mistakes on homeowners and commercial property owners, I think, is a mistake.
Please re-read Mr. Romney's solution as it includes the key elements of this blog's blueprint to save the financial system.
This is the right approach to the problem. If you force the banks to recognize losses on the mortgage debt they are holding, then all of a sudden they will have an incentive to write down debt. Otherwise, a bank will do anything it can to maintain the fiction that the debt is worth 100 cents on the dollar, including lie, harass, and robo-sign.... 
Still, what's shocking about these comments is how casual they are, as if it's common knowledge that the banking system is still insolvent and that our debt loan cannot be paid back. 
Among financial elites, it in fact is common knowledge.
And regular readers of this blog.
Tim Geithner noted this when he talked about Lehman Brothers and the "air in marks" on the debt it was holding on its books. And Martin Feldstein on the Republican side and Alan Blinder on the Democratic side are both arguing for debt write-downs. Everyone knows this has to happen, that the accounting manipulation needs to stop. But Mitt Romney actually said it....
But what this episode shows is that the solutions to our crisis are understood .... We need a debt deal, as Romney inadvertently noted. More fundamentally, getting rid of the accounting gamesmanship will lead to a healthier economy because it will align financial assets with real economic assets.
As another example, credit default swaps are linking American banks excessively to an unstable Eurozone. Credit default swaps are in fact yet another accounting game designed to further balance sheet fictions. 
Which is why banks need to be required to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an on-going basis their current asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.
What Americans should be taking from this episode is that finance, while complex, is not conceptually hard. If it's a lie on the balance sheet, it's going to be destructive to ordinary people. If you stop the balance sheet lying, the economy will do better. But while Mitt Romney might have said this out loud, they all know it behind closed doors. Our question is, who will be the first to make this a policy reality?

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

2012 Davos - The Great Transformation: Shaping New Models

When I saw that the 2012 Davos get together was going to focus on "The Great Transformation: Shaping New Models" presumably to replace the old models that have failed throughout the financial crisis, it naturally caught my attention as both the blueprint for saving the financial system and the FDR Framework on which it is based are transformative new models.

In looking through the 2012 Davos program, I noticed a number of topics that are relevant to the blueprint and the FDR Framework that this blog has discussed extensively.  These topics include

The Future of Economics
What major changes in theory and in practice are driving the rehabilitation of economics?
Dimensions to be addressed:
- The policy and forecasting failures of the past 20 years
- The influence of behavioural and cognitive science
- The impact of the Internet
Will this session address the Queen's Question of how come the economics profession missed the financial crisis and/or the Wall Street Journal's question of what value is economic research?  Will it take up your humble blogger's modest proposal that the three critical assumptions underlying each economic paper must be disclosed up front with a warning statement that if the critical assumptions are not correct then following any recommendation in the paper could be hazardous to the economy?
Big Banks: Cure or Curse for the Global Economy?
From compensation to credit, the fault line between the banking industry and the rest of society continues to widen. Are the world's biggest banks a greater problem than solution to the global recovery?
Will this session discuss lobbying and how Wall Street's Opacity Protection Team has preserved opacity in the financial system that is preventing both the global economy and the financial system from recovering?
Building Trust
When addressing complex, long-term challenges, what effective means best build the trust and
support of key stakeholders?
Dimensions to be addressed:
- Promoting transparency
- Shifting from rules-based to principles-based behaviour
- Moving beyond traditional metrics 
Will this session identify that the foundation for trust in the financial system is disclosure of all the useful, relevant information in an appropriate, timely manner so that market participants can independently assess the risk of an investment?  Will the session conclude that there is a need for ultra transparency in all the opaque corners of the global financial system including banks and structured finance securities?
Corruption and Transparency
What new and effective models can improve transparency and reduce corruption?
Dimensions to be addressed:
- Levelling the playing field
- Monitoring and rewarding tangible results
- Scaling successful partnership models
Will this session adopt ultra transparency as the only way to monitor and reward positive behavior and results in the financial system?
From Data to Decisions
How are new approaches to data intelligence transforming decision-making?
Dimensions to be addressed:
- Redesigning the operational context of organizations
- Navigating a sea of data
- Getting from data to decisions
Will this session present how the "Mother of all financial databases" could be used by all market participants?
Remodelling Capitalism
As the Occupy protests that have spread around the world demonstrate, there is growing frustration with capitalism's failure to benefit the many, rather than just a few. Some argue that capitalism as it stands is an unsustainable system that puts huge strain on the environment and prompts crises that profoundly damage our societies.
- Can capitalism be fixed?
- How can the hopes and expectations of the 99% be fulfilled?
- Where are our priorities when governments bail out banks but leave citizens to struggle?
Will this session focus on the blueprint for saving the financial system?
Shaping new models with technology pioneers
How are disruptive technologies impacting industry and benefitting society?
Will this session feature the "Mother of all Financial Databases" as an example of a disruptive technology that would benefit society?
Beyond Basel: Financial Institution Regulation
In pursuing financing growth while maintaining stability, what regulatory models are the most
effective for financial institutions operating globally?
Dimensions to be addressed:
- Tradeoff between tightening regulation and global growth
- Understanding the impact of Basel III on business models
- Ensuring a level playing field
Will the regulatory model that emerges as the most effective for financial institutions operating globally be based on ultra transparency and the idea of supporting the regulators with both the analytical capability of the market and market discipline?

Monday, January 23, 2012

Will EU banks deepen their dependence on ECB?

Facing a frozen interbank loan market and minimal investor interest in unsecured bank debt, a Bloomberg article looks at whether EU banks will deepen their dependence on the ECB.

Hopefully the banks will.

It is much easier to clean up the losses hidden on and off the banks' balance sheets as recommended under the blueprint for saving the financial system if the banks' funding is stable.  No funding is more stable than the combination of guaranteed deposits, ECB loans and equity.

European banks, shunned by investors and each other, may borrow as much next month from the European Central Bank as they did in a record offering in December as they seek refuge from frozen funding markets. 
The ECB last month lent banks an unprecedented 489 billion euros ($637 billion) for three years. 
Analysts said they expect demand to be just as high at a second auction on Feb. 29 because the stigma associated with using the facility is dissipating and the list of what assets can be used as collateral in exchange for the loans will be extended. 
ECB President Mario Draghi said last week he expects demand for loans next month to be “still very high,” though “probably lower than in December.” 
“February’s second three-year Long Term Refinancing Operation looks set to be extremely large,” Credit Suisse Group AG analysts led by William Porter wrote in a report to clients. “The last LTRO has removed any stigma, making managements who do not exploit the value on offer arguably careless at best.”...
“People aren’t prepared to lend to the banks, so the ECB is just flooding the market with liquidity,” said Christopher Wheeler, an analyst at Mediobanca SpA in London. “But it’s only a temporary fix. The ECB is only buying time with these loans hoping that things will improve.”...
Regular readers know that your humble blogger predicted the freezing of the capital markets to the EU banks as that absence of ultra transparency makes it impossible to determine which banks are solvent and which are not.

In addition, regular readers know that central banks providing liquidity only buys time to address the underlying solvency issue.
Demand from more than 500 lenders in December dwarfed the 293 billion-euro estimate of economists surveyed by Bloomberg News. 
Half of the loans were taken up by Italian and Spanish lenders, Morgan Stanley analyst Huw van Steenis said in a Jan. 18 report to clients. 
Italian banks were the main users, with UniCredit SpA (UCG), the country’s largest lender, taking 12.5 billion euros, Intesa Sanpaolo SpA (ISP), the second-biggest, accepting 12 billion euros, and Banca Monte dei Paschi Di Siena SpA (BMPS) 10 billion euros, the Morgan Stanley analyst estimated, citing conversations with 50 banks and policy makers. Spokesmen for the three banks declined to comment. 
Spain’s Banco Popular Espanol SA (RBS) took 6 billion euros, while Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA (BBVA) used 5 billion euros, according to Morgan Stanley. Bankinter SA (BKT) used 5 billion euros Chief Executive Officer Maria Dolores Dancausa said in a news conference in Madrid on Jan. 18. A spokesman for Popular wasn’t immediately available to comment. BBVA declined to comment.

French banks BNP Paribas (BNP) SA, Societe Generale (GLE) SA, Credit Agricole SA and BPCE SA all borrowed from the ECB though declined to say how much, Morgan Stanley said. Spokespeople for the banks declined to comment. Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc, the U.K.’s largest government-owned lender, took 5 billion pounds ($7.8 billion), according to the analysts. An RBS spokesman declined to comment. 
In all, banks may borrow between 150 billion euros and more than 400 billion euros next month, van Steenis said. “It seems even large cap banks have been open-minded to using this given the size and lack of stigma of the first one,” he wrote....
Given that there is no longer any stigma attached to borrowing from a central bank, central banks and the borrowing banks should fully disclose the loans at the time they are made.
Other analysts said the ECB’s decision to ease the rules on what banks can post in collateral in exchange for the loans could push demand higher. Draghi announced the ECB would relax the collateral requirements at a press briefing on Dec. 8. Details on the new rules have not yet been published. 
“The ECB is still deciding what will constitute acceptable collateral,” Marchel Alexandrovich, an economist at Jefferies International Ltd. in London said. “If criteria are loosened enough, then demand for cheap money will undoubtedly swell up and we may well see a figure in excess of 1 trillion euros” at next month’s operation. 
Credit Suisse’s Porter said he expects banks to borrow slightly more than in December, about 500 billion euros, because lenders won’t want to be put at a competitive disadvantage when their peers can borrow cheaply from the ECB. 
“This will remove some of the refinancing risk the banks face and the markets are reacting positively after a bit of a delay,” Porter said in a telephone interview. “But the more fundamental question is how ‘long can you run a banking system like this?’”
Based on the experience of banks in Japan, the answer is over 2+ decades.

Ultimately, the real question is how does the ECB or any other central bank exit from this program of providing the banks with the funding that the private market refuses to provide.

Regular readers know that the answer to this question is by providing ultra transparency.  It is only when market participants can independently evaluate the solvency of each bank that they will be willing to provide the banks with funding on attractive terms.

Andrew Lilico: "Capitalism is moral when lenders bear responsibility"

Andrew Lilico wrote a Telegraph column on the issue of 'capitalism is moral when lenders bear responsibility'.

As regular readers know, under the blueprint to save the financial system, lenders are going to have to bear responsibility by absorbing the losses on the excesses in the financial system.

Mr. Lilico's column discusses why lenders absorbing losses is consistent with and supportive of moral capitalism.

"Capitalism" is a system for the allocation of capital – of investment. 
Under the (private) capitalist system, those with ideas for businesses but without money to fund them ("entrepreneurs") are free to seek money from those with investment funds available ("capitalists"), and those with investment funds available are free to provide investment for those with ideas but without money. 
If projects work, then the entrepreneur and the capitalists share out the proceeds (exactly how depends on whether the capital is provided as debt or ownership, and various other things that won't concern us here). 
If the project fails, then the capitalists lose some of their money. 
In itself, this is such a transparently good, fair and moral idea that there is absolutely nothing – zero – bad anyone could seriously want to say about it. Who, honestly, wants to stand up and say they think it is per se immoral for those with good ideas but without money to be able to try to get some to fund their ideas?... 
Objections to Capitalism are almost never to the idea in itself. There are three key classes of objection. 
First, there is the objection that it is more expensive to achieve than it is worth. Capitalism requires an extensive panoply of property rights, contract laws, institutions to set and enforce these, typically a medium of exchange (money), somebody to regulate the medium of exchange (a central bank) and many other extremely burdensome things. 
Second, there is the objection that Capitalism is a con. In theory it might involve capitalists losing their money if the project goes bad, but in practice as wealthy people they control the state, and will use their power to prevent themselves from ever making losses. So what people call "Capitalism" is (on this argument) never actually Capitalism – it's always a system of oppression of the poor by the rich dressed up in the garb of a system of fairness and opportunity.... 
Once we understand this – once we really grasp it – we can see what has gone wrong with the system we called "Capitalism" (meaning private Capitalism) recently. 
The problem is that it hasn't been Capitalist. The problem has been that those that lent money – the bondholders and depositors that lent money to banks – did not lose money when their investment projects (i.e. the businesses that were the banks) failed. 
The second critique has been the key one – the system has been a con. In practice, the wealthy have used their political power to insulate themselves against making losses by taxing the poor to keep the foolish / unlucky rich rich. 
David Cameron and others are asking how we might make Capitalism more responsible. 
But Capitalism is all about responsibility – if your ideas don't work, you don't make money; if you fund the wrong projects, you lose your money. 
Capitalism is a system of consequences – failure (through incompetence, laxity or bad luck) has the consequence of loss. 
Consequences for failure is a central part of what Capitalism is about. If failure is forbidden – if the state intervenes to bail out banks, to bail out their bondholders and depositors – then we don't have Capitalism. 
So it is totally absurd and incongruous for any politician that supported bailing out the banks (as Cameron and virtually every other British politician did) to then ask how Capitalism can be made responsible! For all one can say is: "Well, for a start by being Capitalist, which in practice means you and your kin steering clear."

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Telegraph's Liam Halligan: Untying the Gordian Knot of bank balance sheets and sovereign debt

The Telegraph's Liam Halligan looks for a solution to untie the Gordian Knot of Eurozone bank balance sheets and sovereign debt and discovers the fundamental building blocks of this blog's blueprint for saving the financial system.

'Nothing is safe that does not show it can bear discussion and publicity." 
These words, among the many pearls uttered by the celebrated 19th century historian Lord Acton, have often come to me in recent years as the sub-prime crisis has unfolded. They've been particularly on my mind over the past week or so as I've watched events in the eurozone.... 
The relevant observation, though, isn't that France and Spain just managed to auction more debt at lower yields. The relevant observation is "why?" For the reality is that the European Central Bank – whisper it – is now engaged in full-on "stealth monetisation" of the eurozone's hideous, interlocking edifice of bank and sovereign liabilities. This isn't openly admitted, of course, given the German public's acute opposition to "money printing". But it's happening nonetheless. 
The ECB has, for several months now, been aggressively lending to European banks ... This tawdry practice, for sure, is providing eurozone politicians, and their banking sector friends, relief for now. Yet, it cannot go on – which is why, to reprise Lord Acton, it is happening "below the radar". 
Beyond the sly moves, though, the eurozone still faces an imminent, chronic funding problem. Member states need to repay €770bn of debt this year, the bulk of it over the first six months. European banks, themselves heavily dependent on state largesse, have another €520bn of debt coming due by this June, much of it during the first quarter. Berlin appears to have decided that raising the alarm about eurozone QE – for that is what it is – would seriously undermine not only recent stock-market gains (which are helping bank balance sheets look less ghastly) but also upcoming government debt auctions themselves. 
The fundamental issue is that Europe's banks remain locked out of traditional funding markets, leaving them reliant on the ECB – which, in turn, is now increasingly reliant on conjuring-up credits ex nihilo, while begging the Chinese to provide a bail-out. 
Behind last week's triumphant headlines, this is the reality. Faced with a funding freeze, banks are shrinking their balance sheets, of course, strangling growth by refusing to lend, a problem the ECB's black arts will do nothing to address. 
As this blog has repeatedly discussed, central banks providing liquidity buys time to end a solvency problem but is not by itself the solution.
Unable to raise genuine commercial cash, eurozone banks are barely lending even to each other, due to crippling fears of counter-party risk, given that many continue to hide massive liabilities in so-called "special purpose vehicles". European lawmakers, after all, like their UK counterparts, lack the guts to force them to publish their balance sheets in full. 
This remains the nub of the sub-prime problem. The so-called "stress tests" – bank balance-sheet inspections by regulators, who then tell the markets what they think – just won't do.  
Investors themselves need to judge who is solvent and who isn't. Only then can realistic, enduring judgments be made about which banks should and shouldn't survive. 
Capitalism works only when, as Lord Acton might have put it, there is "full disclosure" of all relevant information and creditors can take a meaningful view. 
Please re-read the highlighted sections as it provides an excellent summary of why banks need to be required to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an on-going basis their current asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.
So eurozone governments need to stand behind retail depositors, make the financial institutions "fess-up" and let the cards fall, forcing the bombed-out European banking sector to consolidate. 
This really is the only solution in the eurozone, as well as the UK and US.
Europe's failure to grasp it is more immediately explosive, though, given the political pressures created by being locked into the single currency straitjacket. 
Mr. Halligan has just presented the fundamental building blocks of this blog's blueprint for saving the financial system as the global solution.

Regular readers will recall that the blueprint required banks to provide ultra transparency and for governments to stand behind depositors.
The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision has lately been making noises about requiring banks, when they announce their crucial "tier-one" capital ratios, to reveal how such ratios have been calculated. Outrageously, across the Western world, banks are still permitted to cover this up. In what other industry would such accounting secrecy be tolerated, particularly an industry of such huge systemic importance to the rest of the economy? 
Already, banks are messing with internal "risk-weight" assumptions, in a bid to dodge new rules requiring them to hold more capital. Now they're pushing back against efforts to introduce further, much-needed transparency. Are the politicians reining in the banks, putting them in their place and protecting public interests? Are they heck. 
Some play down the possibility of a "euroquake" and the likely fall-out if one happens. While eurozone nations contributed 20pc of global GDP growth during the 1970s, that share is now way below 10pc, given the new importance of the emerging giants of the East. Having said that, a systemic eurozone banking crisis would rock the world. The financial contagion on asset markets elsewhere would be huge. 
In the end, this eurozone crisis is less about Greek pensions or Italian welfare payments than it is about the region's Gordian knot of entwined bank and sovereign debt. The banks are destroying the governments. And once the governments go down, social unrest will ensue. 
Eurozone banks need to be forced to fess-up, write down their losses and consolidate, yet lawmakers hesitate. That's because our political classes have been "captured" by the financial services sector, a sector allowed to run riot, in recent years, to an ever greater degree. 
"Power tends to corrupt", as Lord Acton famously said, "and absolute power corrupts absolutely".

Saturday, January 21, 2012

What value is economic research?

Regular readers know that this blog is focused on fixing the financial system, however, occasionally I come across an interesting question like the Queen's Question. Here is another example.

A Wall Street Journal blog asks the question of what value is economic research, particularly when it comes from banks who have a stake in the outcome?
Does the economic research produced by academics and banks have any value?
The question was raised in a paper presented to a workshop at Cambridge University in the U.K. a few weeks ago by Stuart Birks of Massey University in New Zealand.
He quoted from earlier research, where economics was described as “being little more than a rhetorical device to persuade people to accept some preferred policy position.” And it is true that much economic research from the big banks and broking houses could be seen as self-serving.
As a colleague at Dow Jones in London wrote recently: Economics is a “discipline hijacked by banks to prove that what makes them most money ought to be government policy.” That may be an exaggeration, but plenty of bank economic research argues, for example, that if banks are forced to write down the value of their peripheral euro-zone bond holdings, the result will be a catastrophe.
Another line that’s common is that a tax on financial transactions or a cap on bonuses would drive the banks from London. Again, this may be true but it’s undeniably self-serving too.
So perhaps it’s time to start a debate similar to the one that raged a few years ago about equity research. Then, there was much head-scratching about whether there was any value in the stock research produced by broking houses that had relationships with the companies being analyzed....
At the moment, we journalists tend to pay more heed to the analysis produced by the major investment banks, but that could well be a mistake.
And maybe governments too should think more deeply about the motives of those suggesting that this or that option would be best. Best for whom? The population at large or just the writers’ employers?
As one of Shakespeare’s characters says about governments and the rich in Coriolanus: “Care for us?… They ne’er cared for us yet. Suffer us to famish, and their store-houses crammed with grain; make edicts for usury, to support usurers; repeal daily any wholesome act established against the rich, and provide more piercing statutes daily to chain up and restrain the poor.”

Adam Smith and the FDR Framework

Regular readers know that this blog is focused on fixing the financial system and not on choosing sides in the long running debate between schools of economic thought.

However, I was reading a post on ZeroHedge where I found a couple of observations by economists that I thought were both interesting and relevant.

Let me read to you from Adam Smith, the section with the invisible hand explanation. He’s with Mises and Hayek on this humility point, even though the book,An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of theWealth of Nations, is written as advice to statesmen: 
“What is the species of domestic industry which his capital can employ [ie what he should invest in], and of which the produce is likely to be of the greatest value, every individual, it is evident, can, in his local situation, judge much better than any statesman or lawgiver can do for him. The statesman, who should attempt to direct private people in which manner they ought to employ their capitals, would not only load himself with a most unnecessary attention, but assume an authority which could safely be trusted, not only to no single person, but to no council or senate, and which would nowhere be so dangerous as in the hands of a man who had folly and presumption enough to fancy himself fit to exercise it.” 
In The Theory of Moral Sentiments Smith calls him “the man of system” who is arrogant in his own conceit. Hayek comes back to this in an essay, “Individualism True and False”, and he tries to explain where the system goes. He writes: 
“The main point about which there can be little doubt, is that Smith’s chief concern was not so much about what man can occasionally achieve when he was at his best, but that he should have as little opportunity as possible to do harm when he was at his worst. It would scarcely be too much to claim that the main merit of the individualism which he and his contemporaries advocated is that it is a system under which bad men can do least harm. It is a social system that does not depend for its functioning on our finding good men for running it, or on all men becoming better than they are now, but which makes use of men in all their given variety and complexity, sometimes good and sometimes bad, sometimes intelligent, and more often stupid. Their aim was a system under which it should be possible to grant freedom to all, instead of restricting it, as their French contemporaries wished, to ‘the good and the wise’. 
“The chief concern of the great individualist writers was indeed to find a set of institutions by which man could be induced, by his own choice and from the motives which determined his ordinary conduct, to contribute as much as possible to the need of all others; and their discovery was that the system of private property did provide such inducements to a much greater extent than had yet been understood.”
The FDR Framework is built on two ideas
  • It is the role of governments to be sure that market participants have access to all the useful, relevant information in an appropriate, timely manner; and
  • Under the principle of caveat emptor investors are responsible for all the gains or losses on their investments.
This framework is consistent with Adam Smith's invisible hand explanation and Hayek's interpretation.

Under the framework, governments are not responsible for making the decisions, but rather for ensuring that the buyer has access to all the useful, relevant information.  It is the buyer that makes and lives with the decision.

With effectiveness of additional liquidity diminishing, central banks show they are not answer to solvency crisis

Mohamed el-Erian wrote an interesting column for Project Syndicate in which he observed that the financial system's credit pipes have remained clogged since the beginning of the crisis in 2008 despite central banks providing massive amounts of liquidity to unclog them.

He then makes several recommendations for how to unclog the credit pipes whose adoption and implementation are independent of the central banks and under the control of global policymakers and regulators.

Several of these recommendations appear in the blueprint for saving the financial system.

More than three years after the global financial crisis, the world still has a nasty plumbing problem. Credit pipes remain clogged, and only central banks are working to clear them. 
But their ability to do so is waning, posing yet another set of risks for western economies blocked by too little growth, too much unemployment, deepening inequality, and debt in all the wrong places. 
Fortunately, it is not too late to build broader pipes that complement and replace the damaged infrastructure.... 
Central banks providing liquidity only buys time for the underlying solvency problem to be addressed.  By itself, liquidity does not fix the problem.  Mr. el-Erian confirms this with his observation that the credit pipes are still clogged despite all the liquidity central banks are providing.
The current situation embodies two narratives that seem contradictory, but are not.
One speaks to the reality that most large companies with access to capital markets have no problem securing new funding. In fact, they have been remarkably successful in lengthening their debt maturities, accumulating cash, and lowering their future interest payments. In sum, they now have "fortress" balance sheets. 
The other narrative speaks to an opposing, but equally valid reality. Too many small companies and households still find it difficult to borrow at reasonable terms. This includes those reliant on bank credit, as well as many mortgage holders with very high legacy interest rates and balances that exceed their homes' market value. 
From every angle, the extremity of this state of affairs – in which those with access to credit do not need it, and those who do cannot get it – is highly problematic.... 
In the next round, as the system slowly implodes, even those with healthy balance sheets would be impacted, accelerating their disengagement from a deleveraging world economy.
All of this slows social mobility, tears already-stretched safety nets, worsens inequality, and accentuates genuine concerns about the functioning and sustainability of today's global economic system....

At the beginning of the financial crisis, your humble blogger observed that until opacity was eliminated in the financial system, we would continue in a downward spiral.  Mr. el-Erian confirms this and describes how he sees the mechanism behind the downward spiral working.

Central banks have recognised all of this for some time, prompting them to take enormous reputational and operational risks to slow the process. They have implemented a host of "unconventional policies" that previously would have been deemed unthinkable, even outrageous – and that can be seen in the enormous growth in their balance sheets. 
In the last four years, the United States Federal Reserve's balance sheet has more than tripled, from under $1 trillion (£645bn) to a mammoth $3tn. The growth relative to the size of the economy is even more stunning – from slightly more than 5% of GDP to 20%. The Bank of England's balance sheet is also at 20% of GDP. And both seem to be itching to do even more. 
The European Central Bank is often viewed as a laggard. No longer. Its balance sheet has now doubled, to a whopping 30% of GDP – and it, too, appears set to do even more. Mario Draghi, the ECB's new president, recently said that he expects heavy take-up on the next three-year long-term refinancing operation, a powerful tool to pump cheap liquidity into the banks. 
Unfortunately, the economic outcomes have come nowhere close to matching the intensity of these efforts. Effectively, the central banks have been unconventional bridges to nowhere, owing mainly to their imperfect tools and other government agencies' inability or unwillingness to act. At some point – and we are nearing it – bridges to nowhere become a standalone risk: they can topple over....
The financial system is facing a solvency problem as the result of its credit bubble bursting.  As Japan has shown after 2+ decades of unconventional central bank policies, liquidity does not fix a solvency problem.

With its blueprint for saving the financial system, this blog has laid out how the solvency problem could be fixed.  What follows is Mr. el-Erian's proposed cures.
It is high time to move on five fronts, simultaneously: 
• Countries such as Spain and the US need to be more forceful in unblocking the housing sector by making overdue decisions on burden sharing, refinancing, and conversion of idle and foreclosed housing stock.
• Countries with excessive debt, such as Greece and Portugal, need to impose sizeable "haircuts" on creditors to have a reasonable chance of restoring medium-term debt sustainability and growth.

Under this blog's blueprint, Wall Street rescues Main Street by stepping up and absorbing the losses on the financial excesses whether these excesses be mortgage-related or sovereign debt.

There are a number of reasons that Wall Street should absorb these losses including 1) it is the responsibility of a lender to be prudent in their credit judgments and not to extend more credit than the borrower can repay; and 2) banks are beneficiaries of both deposit insurance and access to central bank liquidity and therefore are in a position to recapitalize themselves through retention of future earnings.

• In several western countries, public-private partnerships should be formed to finance urgently needed infrastructure investment.
Under this blog's blueprint, banks recapitalize themselves through retention of future earnings.  This frees up governments to spend money on stimulating economic growth including making infrastructure investments.
• Regulators should stop bickering about the future configuration of key financial institutions, and instead set a clearer multi-year vision that is also consistent across borders.
Requiring banks to adopt ultra transparency is the only regulation that needs to be globally adopted.  There is no ambiguity in banks disclosing on an on-going basis their current asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

With ultra transparency, financial institutions become subject to global market discipline.  This discipline, through higher cost of funds based on the risk of the individual financial institutions, will force the financial institutions to reduce their complexity and risk profile.
• Finally, governments should inform their electorates explicitly and comprehensively that a few contracts written during the inadvisable "great age" of leverage, debt, and credit entitlements cannot be met, and must be rewritten in a transparent way that strikes a balance between generations, labour and capital, and recipients and taxpayers.
See Wall Street absorbing losses on financial excesses above.
Such policies would allow healthy balance sheets around the world, both public and private, to engage in a pro-growth and pro-jobs process. They require leadership, focus, and education. Absent that, plumbing problems will become more acute, and the repairs more complex and threatening to virtually everyone – including both the "one percenters" and those who worrisomely are struggling at the margins of society.

How banks get away with inventing profits

The Guardian ran an interesting column on 'bankers now producing financial statements that would make Bernie Madoff blush'.

The key takeaway from the column is bank financial statements are meaningless.  This is further confirmation of the observation made by the OECD that bank capital ratios, which are based on balance sheet figures, are also meaningless.

As this blog has said repeatedly, the only way to restore confidence in the financial statements is by requiring banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose their current asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

With this information, market participants can determine just how fictional the current bank financial statements are and the size of the adjustment these statements require to bring them back to reflecting reality.

The banking crisis is now out of control, made worse by the sloppy bailout structure. The format of the bailout, and the perverse incentives for managers created thereby, have encouraged senior executives to produce financial statements that are still exaggerating profits and capital to an extent that would make Bernie Madoff blush. 
Let me set out three examples of how bankers declare profits despite running loss-making operations as defined by prevailing UK company law, some of which were acknowledged by the Bank of England's Andy Haldane on Thursday: 
1. Underprovisioning for expected losses, resulting in loans being carried at more than their recoverable amounts.... 
2. Marking to model
Under IFRS rules, certain assets (primarily derivatives and heavily structured transactions), for which there is no market, are valued by analogous reference to a synthetic imagined market. The aforementioned Madoff employed this method of accounting. 
3. Fair valuing own debt 
A healthy banking system is characterised by a market environment in which all major entities strong enough to enjoy the revered accreditation "bank" are believed to be solvent. 
When confidence in a bank's solvency drops, the market price of that bank's debt falls. To wipe out a £1bn operating loss by recording a £2.3bn profit based on the assumption that the bank could repurchase all of its debt at the discounted market price is crazy. RBS did this in 2011 Q3.