Showing posts with label Article 122a: Know What You Own. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article 122a: Know What You Own. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

Bank of France turns to "super" transparency to restart securitization in EU

Bloomberg reports that the Bank of France is rolling out what it believes is the model for restarting securitization in the EU.

The distinguishing feature of the Bank of France's model is the reliance on making these deals "super transparent" so that market participants can know what they are buying and know what they own.

This is precisely what your humble blogger has been calling for since the earliest days of the financial crisis.

Why would the Bank of France feel the need to roll out deals that are "super transparent" when the ECB has already endorsed the level of transparency provided by the EU DataWarehouse?

Because the Bank of France sees that the EU DataWarehouse doesn't bring transparency that would allow an investor to know what they own or a buyer to know what they are buying.  Rather, the EU DataWarehouse is the industry's effort to retain opacity at the levels associated with opaque, toxic subprime mortgage-backed securities.

Please note, that the Bank of France recognizes that the only way to reduce, if not totally eliminate, the rating firms' role in securitization is to make the deal "super transparent".  When a deal is "super transparent", reliance on rating firms is greatly reduced as investors can do the analysis for themselves or hire a third party expert.

Regular readers know that your humble blogger has defined what it takes for a structured finance deal to be "super transparent".

First, the deal must provide observable event based reporting under which all activities, like a payment or delinquency, involving the underlying collateral are reported to market participants before the beginning of the next business day.

Second, the deal must make available all data fields tracked by the originator of the underlying collateral and the servicer of this collateral.  These firms are experts and would only track data fields that are relevant for valuing or monitoring the underlying collateral.  There is no legitimate business reason for depriving market participants of the right to piggy-back off this expertise.

The Bank of France wants to help banks package loans to businesses into tradable securities with the creation of a special-purpose vehicles, in what could become a template for the euro area. 
As the European Central Bank looks for ways to improve the flow of credit to small and medium-sized enterprises, or SMEs, the project started by the French central bank in July last year could provide one possible solution, the head of its markets division, Alexandre Gautier, said in a telephone interview. 
He’s in talks with the Frankfurt-based ECB and other national central banks on the initiative, which would ideally create securities that qualify as collateral in ECB refinancing operations. While banks can currently securitize SME loans and use them as collateral at the ECB, the process is complicated and not centralized. 
“We want a vehicle that is super simple and super transparent,” Gautier said. “We’d very much like these securities to be eligible in the euro system, but it’s not a condition. We’ll go ahead on our own if we have to to show that it’s doable.”... 
The aim is to make it easier for banks to re-finance existing loans and incentivize them to extend credit to small businesses. That would especially be the case if the new securities were eligible as collateral with the ECB, said Gautier. 
“The banks were very interested but they said that to make it really attractive, any securities should be eligible as collateral for refinancing within the euro system so that they would be liquid in the event of a crisis,” he said. “That’s now what we’re aiming for.” 
ECB President Mario Draghi said on May 2 that policy makers will start consultations with other European institutions on initiatives to promote lending to SMEs in the euro area using asset-backed securities.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Robert Shiller: Capitalism and Financial Innovation

At the 2012 CFA Institute Financial Analysts Seminar, Yale professor Robert Shiller laid out his views on capitalism and financial innovation.

Professor Shiller channeled his inner Gary Gorton, another Yale Professor whose work on informationally insensitive debt and safe assets your humble blogger has previously debunked, and talked about the benefits of financial innovation, in particular securitization.

According to Professor Shiller,
The ideas I posit are basically an appreciation of financial innovation. Today, cynicism and skepticism regarding financial innovation abound.
Your humble blogger is neither a cynic or a skeptic.  I simply subscribe to Yves Smith's maxim:  nobody on Wall Street is compensated for creating low margin, transparent products.

Financial innovation is primarily about how to create opacity so that the bankers can extract excess rent from investors who are gambling on the value of the opaque innovation rather than investing in a transparent investment.
Even former Fed chairman Paul Volcker contributes to these views. A couple years ago, he famously said that he couldn’t think of any useful financial innovation within recent memory besides ATMs. 
What Volcker says gets a big audience, but I couldn’t disagree with him more.
Which puts the burden on Professor Shiller to show a financial innovation that is actually useful for something other than extracting excess rent from investors (we'll get to that when he talks about securitization).
Our civilization is built on financial innovation. Finance begets and supports almost all activities; it makes the world turn in a modern and civilized way. 
Innovation is necessary if finance is to remain relevant as a means of achieving society’s goals. Perhaps what I have to say will help the finance community defend itself better and encourage finance professionals to assume personal responsibility for their role in making markets more efficient....
This is quite a statement as most people would think that it is the real economy and its inventions that built our civilization.

Finance certainly has a role in supporting the real economy, but it is not at all clear that it is financial innovation that lead the real economy and its inventions and built our civilization.
Securitization was an innovation that blew up in the latest crisis because the process was fraught with errors. 
The most notable error in securitization was in real estate—the subprime loan securitization, which blew up because people didn’t appreciate the risk that home prices would fall. 
It is misleading to say that people didn't appreciate the risk that home prices would fall as a drop in home prices is not what caused the losses on these securities.

What caused the losses was that the borrowers were not making payments on their mortgages.

Since the value of these securities is based on the ongoing payments on the mortgages, so long as the borrowers are paying on their mortgages, the security is performing regardless of what is happening to the price of the house the mortgage is secured against.

Perhaps Professor Shiller never heard the expression "opaque, toxic sub-prime mortgage-backed securities".


What made these securities so dangerous to investors' wealth was that opacity hid their true toxicity.

Specifically, the lack of observable event based reporting on all activities like a payment or delinquency on the underlying collateral before the beginning of the next business day made it impossible for market participants to know what they were buying or know what they owned.

Your humble blogger has demonstrated this numerous times using a Brown Paper Bag to represent a security using current industry disclosure practices and a Clear Plastic Bag to represent a security using observable event based reporting.

As a concept, however, securitization will survive because it is a means through which a large number of people benefit.
I happen to agree with Professor Shiller that securitization will survive.  The question is whether it will survive in its current opaque form that allows bankers to extract excess rent from investors or in a transparent form where it supports society.
Securitization is an innovation designed to solve an asymmetric information problem.
Actually, as Wall Street uses securitization, it is an innovation designed to create an asymmetric information problem.

The asymmetry is that Wall Street has the information on the current performance of the underlying collateral (they see these securities as if they are Clear Plastic Bags) and the rest of the market place has out of date performance information (they see these securities as they truly are, Brown Paper Bags).

This information asymmetry effectively lets Wall Street trade on tomorrow's news today.

As the financial crisis showed, Wall Street is more than willing to take advantage of this information asymmetry at the expense of the investors.
In the case of the mortgage market, mortgages and thus mortgage-backed bonds require a lot of analysis that many investors are unable to do, so without securitization, those investors would forgo investing in this market.
By securitizing mortgages, tranches of similar credit quality are created, allowing a large swath of the general investing population to buy mortgage-backed bonds that they otherwise would not buy. 
Professor Shiller's observation about the need for analysis reminds me of Professor Gorton's theory on informationally insensitive debt.

Professor Gorton cited bank deposits as an example of informationally insensitive debt.  There is one small problem with this example.  Bank deposits are insured and depositors are very sensitive to this fact.  Confirmation of this can be seen in Greece and Spain where doubts have arisen about whether deposit insurance will be honored and depositors have pulled their money.

Regular readers know that our financial system is based on the FDR Framework under which the government is responsible for ensuring that all useful, relevant information is disclosed in an appropriate, timely manner and investors are given the incentive to use this information as they are responsible for all losses on their investments.

Investors know this.  As a result, if investors cannot assess the information on the mortgages themselves, rather than forgo making an investment they simply engage third party experts who can assess the information.

Individuals hire portfolio managers.  Portfolio managers, if they or their organization cannot do the analysis themselves, hire third party experts.

The simple point is that if there is transparency and all the useful, relevant information is disclosed in an appropriate, timely manner, it is used by investors so they can make a fully informed investment decision for any type of investment.

Unfortunately, current securitizations are opaque and there is no information for investors to analyze.  As a result, buying or selling these securities is nothing more than gambling on the contents of a Brown Paper Bag.
Thus, mortgage securitization creates a financial market that allows many people to buy homes that they otherwise might not be able to buy, and it also lowers mortgage rates. 
Isn't one of the problems we have is that people bought houses that they couldn't afford?
The theory of finance involves asymmetric information as one of the elements that financial professionals have to engineer and design around. 
Please re-read the highlighted text again as Professor Shiller has effectively praised Wall Street for creating high margin, opaque products where Wall Street has an asymmetric information advantage.

What is good for society is when financial products are designed to eliminate asymmetric information.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

JP Morgan e-mails show with current loan-level performance information investors could have known how bad deals were

Since the beginning of the financial crisis, your humble blogger has been saying that if structured finance securities offer observable event based reporting on all activities like payments and delinquencies involving the underlying collateral before the beginning of the next business day, investors could know what they own or what they are buying.

The New York Times' Dealbook ran an article on JP Morgan where a series of e-mails confirms that observable event based reporting would allow investors to know what they own or what they are buying.

Equally importantly, the article establishes that observable event based reporting is necessary if the information advantage currently enjoyed by Wall Street is going to be eliminated.  Without this information advantage being eliminated, investors will be reluctant to return to this market as they recall how much money they lost due to Wall Street's use of this informational advantage.

When an outside analysis uncovered serious flaws with thousands of home loans, JPMorgan Chase executives found an easy fix. 
Rather than disclosing the full extent of problems like fraudulent home appraisals and overextended borrowers, the bank adjusted the critical reviews, according to documents filed early Tuesday in federal court in Manhattan. 
As a result, the mortgages, which JPMorgan bundled into complex securities, appeared healthier, making the deals more appealing to investors.
Please re-read the highlighted text as it nicely summarizes why observable event based reporting must be a requirement for all structured finance deals.
The trove of internal e-mails and employee interviews, filed as part of a lawsuit by one of the investors in the securities, offers a fresh glimpse into Wall Street’s mortgage machine, which churned out billions of dollars of securities that later imploded. 
The documents reveal that JPMorgan, as well as two firms the bank acquired during the credit crisis, Washington Mutual and Bear Stearns, flouted quality controls and ignored problems, sometimes hiding them entirely, in a quest for profit.
Let me repeat, the profits from Wall Street's information advantage comes from having tomorrow's news today.  Wall Street had access to observable event based reporting on the underlying mortgages and the investors did not.

When it comes to rewriting disclosure regulations for structured finance securities, Wall Street is protecting its access to tomorrow's news today.  It does this through the sell-side dominated industry trade groups, the American Securitization Forum (ASF) and the Association for Financial Markets in Europe (AFME), that keep lobbying the global financial regulators to focus on data templates and NOT when the data is disclosed.
The lawsuit, which was filed by Dexia, a Belgian-French bank, is being closely watched on Wall Street. 
After suffering significant losses, Dexia sued JPMorgan and its affiliates in 2012, claiming it had been duped into buying $1.6 billion of troubled mortgage-backed securities. 
The latest documents could provide a window into a $200 billion case that looms over the entire industry. In that lawsuit, the Federal Housing Finance Agency, which oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, has accused 17 banks of selling dubious mortgage securities to the two housing giants. At least 20 of the securities are also highlighted in the Dexia case, according to an analysis of court records....
The Dexia lawsuit centers on complex securities created by JPMorgan, Bear Stearns and Washington Mutual during the housing boom. As profits soared, the Wall Street firms scrambled to pump out more investments, even as questions emerged about their quality.... 
JPMorgan routinely hired Clayton Holdings and other third-party firms to examine home loans before they were packed into investments. Combing through the mortgages, the firms searched for problems like borrowers who had vastly overstated their incomes or appraisals that inflated property values. 
According to the court documents, an analysis for JPMorgan in September 2006 found that “nearly half of the sample pool” — or 214 loans — were “defective,” meaning they did not meet the underwriting standards. The borrowers’ incomes, the firms found, were dangerously low relative to the size of their mortgages. 
Another troubling report in 2006 discovered that thousands of borrowers had already fallen behind on their payments....
Please re-read the highlighted text as it shows that if the investors had access to the underlying mortgages on an observable event based reporting basis, they too could have known that the mortgages were bad.

Investors could have done the analysis for themselves or hired an expert like Clayton Holdings.

What is important here is that if there had been observable event based disclosure, these deals would never have been done on the terms they were done on.

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Structured finance investors: current proposed disclosure standards inadequate

A 2012 Q4 survey of investors in asset-backed securities, mortgage-backed securities and structured credit securities by Principia reveals that 59% of these investors think that the proposed loan level disclosure standards will not be sufficient to adequately perform due diligence.

We asked investors whether the current standards for disclosure of loan level data, for example via the European DataWarehouse, Project RESTART, EDGAR or the BoE and ECB templates, will provide sufficient data to adequately perform due diligence on ABS/MBS/CDO investments.... 
59% remain unsure as to whether the new market standards will be sufficient. This is a general finding across all asset classes...
Please re-read the highlighted text and as you are doing so ask yourself what percentage of portfolio managers would say that IBM's disclosures are sufficient to adequately perform due diligence (your humble blogger would expect 90+% as no one refers to IBM as a 'black box').

Regular readers are not surprised by this survey result.  It confirms what your humble blogger has been saying about the sell-side and its lobbyists like ASF, AFME (formerly ESF) derailing efforts to bring greater transparency to structured finance securities.

Regular readers know that there are two aspects to disclosure:  what is disclosed and when it is disclosed.

To date, the sell-side has managed to prevent adequate loan level disclosure standards by focusing the discussion on what is disclosed in the specific data fields in the templates proposed by ESF, Project Restart, EDGAR, the BoE and the ECB.

While very time consuming, this whole discussion of specific data fields to include in the templates ignores a simple relevant fact: the data fields that should be disclosed are all the data fields tracked by the loan originator and servicer that are not borrower privacy protected.

The originator and servicer are experts and as such every field that they track is a field that they feel is important for monitoring and valuing the individual loan.  These experts wouldn't track a data field they didn't think was important because it costs them money.

However, even if the disclosure templates were thrown away and all the data fields tracked by the originators and servicers were provided to investors, this would not be a big enough change in disclosure to get remotely close to 90+% thinking the disclosure was sufficient to adequately perform due diligence.

The simple fact is that investors recognize that 'when' data is disclose is a critical factor in determining if the disclosure is adequate for performing due diligence.

Structured finance securities are created by setting aside specific assets for the benefit of the investors.  The physical equivalent of this would be to put these assets in a bag.

'When' addresses the question of is the bag paper or plastic.

It is a brown paper bag if 'when' is the same reporting frequency as exists for opaque subprime mortgage-backed securities.  This is the frequency that has been adopted by the sell-side and shows up in the European Data Warehouse and Project Restart.

The bag is plastic if 'when' is observable event based reporting under which all activities like a payment or delinquency involving the underlying assets are reported to market participants before the beginning of the next business day.

It is only be adopting observable event based reporting with all the non-borrow privacy protected data fields tracked by the originators and servicers that 90+% of structured finance investors will think the disclosure was sufficient to adequately perform due diligence.

Other Interesting Observations

1) The investors have confessed that when it comes to buying ABS/MBS/CDO securities they are blindly gambling on the contents of a brown paper bag.

59% of investors are saying that the proposed standards are not sufficient to adequately perform due diligence.  If the proposed standards are not sufficient, what does that say about existing disclosure standards?

2) The proposed disclosure standards are unlikely to encourage former or new investors to buy ABS/MBS/CDO securities.

If 59% of existing investors see themselves as blindly gambling on the contents of a brown paper bag because of disclosure is not sufficient to adequately perform due diligence, why would former or new investors want to gamble too?


Tuesday, January 29, 2013

SEC Commissioner Troy Paredes: Sophisticated investors better at valuing contents of brown paper bag

In an astonishing report by Securitization Intelligence, in his keynote address at the ASF 2013 conference, SEC Commissioner Troy Paredes offered
his views on Regulation AB II’s requirement that private 144a offerings include elements of disclosure usually limited to publicly registered transactions, saying that he has previously expressed concern “that we were going too far in treating the private market just like the public market, and that, as a consequence of that, we may compromise the value that the private market brings to bear.” 
He added that the thought that the relative lack of legal protections for investors in the private-label market makes such disclosure requirements important is obviated in part by the sophistication of the investors in the space. 
“I remain unpersuaded that the fundamental reason that the securitization market has been struggling in the last few years is because we don’t have a piling on of regulatory demands,” he said. 
“That’s not to say there is not some room for improvement” in disclosure enhancements, but that the SEC could “end up undercutting the objective of trying to move the ball forward when it comes to the securitization market being conditioned to take off again.” 
To which Deutsch replied, on behalf of attendees who received less resolute answers from some regulatory panelists yesterday, “Hallelujah, brother.” [confirming that ASF is a sell-side dominated group and doesn't represent the buy-side's interests.]
As long as Commissioner Paredes brought up the issue, I thought I might describe exactly what disclosure requirements are needed for both publicly registered and private 144a offerings.

From my post, Turning lemon mortgage-backed securities into lemonade
Disclosure has two components:  what is disclosed and when it is disclosed.  I would like to focus on “when” it is disclosed. 
Everyone knows that structured finance securities involve taking specific assets, like mortgages, and setting them aside for the benefit of the investor.  The physical equivalent of this would be to put them into a bag.

Once the mortgages are in the bag, it is important to know what is in the bag currently. 
 Why? 
If an investor does not know what is in the bag currently, they cannot take the first step in the investment cycle.  
The first step is to independently assess the risk and value the underlying collateral so the investor can know what the investor is buying and, after buying, know what they own. 
The second step is to compare this independent assessment to the prices shown by Wall Street. 
The third and final step is to make a buy, hold or sell decision based on the difference between the investor’s independent valuation of the security and the price shown by Wall Street. 
Please note that without the ability to know what is in the bag currently, it is impossible to accurately assess what is going to come out of the bag eventually. The lack of knowing what is in the bag currently prevents investors from performing their own independent assessment and makes meaningless hiring an expert third party to do the assessment for them.  
Simply put, without current information of what is in the bag, investors cannot go through the investment cycle. 
Buying securities in the absence of an independent assessment is not investing.  Buying securities that cannot be independently assessed is the equivalent of blindly betting on the contents of a brown paper bag.  And, once the securities are purchased, the investor has no ability to know what they own. 
In case you doubt this, let me show it to you using a brown paper bag to hold the underlying collateral. 
On the first business day of last month, $100 went into the bag.  On the third business day of this month, a trustee report with granular level data was issued that showed the bag contained $75 at the end of the last month.  This was made up of 3 $20 bills and 3 $5 bills. 
So the question is:  what is in the bag currently? 
Based on the fact that $25 came out of the bag last month, there are a number of ways of guessing what is in the brown paper bag? First, we could guess that nothing has been taken out of the bag and it still holds $75. Or a $5 bill has been removed and left $70 in the bag.  Or a $20 bill has been removed and left $55 in the bag?  Or both a $5 bill and a $20 bill have been removed and left $50 in the bag? 
By simply asking what is in the brown paper bag currently, I have already created a $25 spread between the $75 a seller might reasonably value the contents of the brown paper bag at and the $50 a buyer might be willing to offer. 
Let me assure you that with this wide a spread, the contents of the brown paper bag are not going to sell. 
This valuation problem has been shown to be particularly acute for mortgage-backed securities since the beginning of the financial crisis.  At that time, buyers came to doubt the ability of the borrowers to make their future payments.  The more doubt, the more likely the market is to freeze as it is impossible to get buyers, who think that the bag is more likely to have $50, and sellers, who look at last month's performance and think the bag has $75, to agree on price. 
Another way we can approach asking what is currently in this brown paper bag is to use a sophisticated model.  We recognize that last month $25 came out of the bag.  This is roughly $0.85 per day.  So we can value the contents of the brown paper bag by multiplying the day of the month it is today by .85 and subtracting the resulting value from the end of the month value shown in the last trustee report. 
Today is the 6th, so the model suggests a value of $69.90 ($75 minus $5.10).  The price suggested by the model doesn't seem unreasonable if a $5 bill is removed from the bag. 
However, a buyer is significantly overpaying if there has been a sharper decline in the value of collateral in the bag and a $20 bill has been removed.  This is analogous to what happened with sub-prime mortgage-backed securities where there was a rapid decline in the value of the collateral. 
This problem of guessing what is in the bag would go away if we were talking about a clear plastic bag.  The investor would know what is in the bag currently as the contents of the bag can be seen and are a knowable fact. 
This is true whether the investor is Commissioner Paredes' sophisticated investor or not.
As a result, investors could independently assess the risk and value the collateral.  With this assessment, the investor “knows what they are buying” and "knows what they own". With this assessment, the investor can make an investment decision to buy, hold or sell based on the prices being shown by Wall Street. 
So turning the mortgage market from lemons to lemonade simply requires recognizing that it is a choice between “Paper or Plastic”.  With “Paper”, you get lemons.  With “Plastic”, you get lemonade. 
So how can each of the structured finance securities be put into the equivalent of a clear plastic bag? 
This can be easily done as the servicer information systems are designed to track and report on the underlying collateral on an observable event basis. 
With observable event based disclosure where all activities like a payment or delinquency involving the underlying collateral are reported before the beginning of the next business day, the investor knows what is in the bag currently. 
Observable event based disclosure is associated with a clear plastic bag.  All other frequencies of disclosure are associated with a brown paper bag and lemons.

Wednesday, January 23, 2013

What did Wall Street know and When did they know it when selling CDOs?

In an excellent article, Jesse Eisinger looks at the questions of what did Wall Street know and when did they know it as it relates to the construction and sale of subprime mortgage-backed CDOs.

Specifically, Mr. Eisinger focuses on Morgan Stanley and a particularly toxic CDO called Stack 2006-1.

Regular readers know that Wall Street had the equivalent of "tomorrow's new today" that it used in the construction of these CDOs.  The source of this information was their subprime mortgage origination and servicing platforms.

Specifically, whether they bought the mortgages from a third party or originate the mortgages themselves, the Wall Street firms knew just how quickly the quality of the underwriting of the mortgages was deteriorating.

From their servicing of the mortgages, Wall Street could see that the poorly underwritten mortgages were defaulting at a faster rate than the models used to value subprime mortgage-backed securities predicted.

Of course, Wall Street used this information to its advantage when it came to constructing and selling CDOs.

That is why the market for non-government guaranteed structured finance securities is frozen.  Investors are on a buyers' strike until such time as this informational advantage is eliminated.

The only way to eliminate Wall Street's informational advantage is to require that the structured finance securities provide observable event based information and report all activities like payments or defaults involving the underlying collateral before the beginning of the next business day.

With this information, investors can know what they are buying and subsequently know what they own.  Otherwise, they are simply gambling on the value of the contents of a brown paper bag that Wall Street has sold to them at a price that is higher than the contents are worth.

As Mr. Eisinger describes it:

Hundreds of pages of internal Morgan Stanley documents, released publicly last week, shed much new light on what bankers knew at the height of the housing bubble and what they did with that secret knowledge. 
The lawsuit concerns a $500 million collateralized debt obligation called Stack 2006-1, created in the first half of 2006. Collections of mortgage-backed securities, C.D.O.'s were at the heart of the financial crisis. 
But the documents suggest a pattern of behavior larger than this one deal: People across the bank understood that the American housing market was in trouble. They took advantage of that knowledge to create and then bet against securities and then also to unload garbage investments on unsuspecting buyers. 
Morgan Stanley doesn't see the narrative as the plaintiffs do. The firm is fighting the lawsuit, contending that the buyers were sophisticated clients and could have known what was going on in the subprime market. 
The C.D.O. documents disclosed, albeit obliquely, that Morgan Stanley might bet against the securities, a strategy known as shorting. The firm did not pick the assets going into the deal (though it was able to veto any assets). And any shorting of the deal was part of a larger array of trades, both long and short. Indeed, Morgan Stanley owned a big piece of Stack, in addition to its short bet.....

In February 2006, Morgan Stanley began putting together the Stack C.D.O. According to an internal presentation, Stack "represents attractive business for Morgan Stanley." 
Why? In addition to fees, another bullet point listed: "Ability to short up to $325MM of credits into the C.D.O." In other words, Morgan Stanley could — and did — sell assets to the Stack C.D.O., intending to profit if the securities backed by those assets declined. The bank put on a $170 million bet against Stack, even as it was selling it. 
In the end, of the $500 million of assets backing the deal, $415 million ended up worthless....
It certainly helps when selecting assets to short if you have material information regarding their performance that the other side of the deal does not have.

Perhaps more importantly, the other side cannot get this material information unless it too happens to have a subprime mortgage origination and servicing platform.
Why might Morgan Stanley have bet against the deal? 
Did its traders develop a brilliant thesis by assessing the fundamentals of the housing market through careful analysis of the public data? 
The documents suggest something more troubling: Bankers found out that the housing market was diseased from their colleagues down the hall.
Please re-read the highlighted text as Mr. Eisinger nicely summarizes the source of Wall Street's informational advantage.  A source that would be able to provide insight into exactly what securities should be selected to maximize the profitability of the short.
Bankers were getting information from fellow employees conducting and receiving private assessments of the quality of the mortgages that the bank would purchase to back securities.
Readers might recall that Morgan Stanley owned a subprime mortgage origination and servicing firm called Saxon Capital.  The Wall Street Journal wrote about how information from Saxon informed Morgan Stanley's trades.
These reports weren't available to the public.
It would be crucial information for trading in securities backed by those kinds of mortgages.....
In fact, mortgage-backed securities are constructed to delay the public's access to data and give Wall Street a permanent information advantage.

By design, mortgage-backed securities report the performance of the underlying mortgages once per month.  These reports come out from 5 to 10 business days after the month ends.

Contrast this with the reports that a servicing firm generates.  They generate a report every single day.  At a minimum, Wall Street would know how all the loans in a deal performed several business days before investors and other market participants.

Wall Street showed with the CDOs that it was fully capable of using its access to "tomorrow's news today" to generate a lot of money.
Two of the employees who received those emails joined an internal hedge fund, headed by Howard Hubler, that was formed only the following month, in April 2006. 
As recounted in Michael Lewis's "The Big Short," Mr. Hubler infamously bet against the subprime market on Morgan Stanley's behalf, a fact that Morgan Stanley's chief financial officer conceded in late 2007. 
Mr. Hubler's group was supposed to be separate from the rest of Morgan Stanley, but the two bankers continued to receive similar information about the underlying market, according to the person briefed on the matter. 
At no point did they receive material, nonpublic information, a Morgan Stanley spokesman says. 
I struggle to see how the private assessments that the subprime market was imploding were immaterial.
It was not necessarily the private assessments that the subprime market was imploding that was material.  Rather, it was the data that showed the subprime market was imploding that was material.

Data that the origination and servicing platform would routinely generate.
But let's review what the documents suggest is the big picture. 
In the fall of 2005, bank employees share nonpublic assessments of how the subprime market is a house of tarot cards. 
In February 2006, the bank begins creating Stack in part so that it can bet against it. 
In April 2006, the bank creates its own internal hedge fund, led by Mr. Hubler, who shorts the subprime market. Among the traders in this internal shop are people who helped create Stack and other deals like it, and at least two employees who had access to the private due diligence reports. 
Mr. Hubler's group had no investment position in Stack, according to a person briefed on the matter, but it sure looks as if the bank saw what was coming and tried to position itself for a subprime market collapse. 
Finally, by early 2007, the bank appears to realize that the subprime market is cratering even worse that it expects. Even the supposedly safe pieces of C.D.O.'s that it owns, including its piece of Stack, are facing losses. So Morgan Stanley bankers set to scouring the world to peddle as a safe and sound investment what its own employees are internally deriding. 
Morgan Stanley declined to comment on whether it made money on its Stack investments over all. But it looks to have turned out well for the bank. In Stack, it managed to fob off a nuclear bomb to the Taiwanese bank.

Friday, January 18, 2013

CFPB mortgage servicing rules eliminate excuses not to provide transparency for RMBS

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau announced its new mortgage servicing rules that eliminate any excuse the structured finance industry has for not providing observable event based reporting on residential mortgage-backed securities.

Under the new rules, mortgage servicers, the firms that manage the loans, will now be required to credit a borrower's account the day a payment is receive.  In addition, the mortgage servicers must provide borrowers with regular statements that show a breakdown of payments by principal, interest, fees, and escrow as well as recent account activity.

For anyone who is familiar with looking up their credit card account on-line, the CFPB has said that mortgage servicing firms need to provide similar information in a timely manner.  From an IT perspective, this is easy to do because both mortgages and credit card databases update whenever there is activity on the account.

I can not stress enough the importance of the CFPB's mortgage servicing rules.  The ability of mortgage servicers to comply with these rules means by definition that observable event based reporting can be provided for all residential mortgage-backed securities.

As regular readers know, observable event based reporting involves reporting all activities like payments or delinquencies involving the underlying collateral to market participants before the next business day.

This is the same information that mortgage servicers need to "report" to borrowers.

As a result, there is no longer any excuse for the structured finance industry to block the provision of observable event based reporting.
To prevent harm to consumers in routine payment processing, our rules also require common-sense policies and procedures. Payments must be promptly credited as of the day they are received.... 
In general, servicers must maintain accurate and accessible documents and records. They must be able to provide accurate and timely information to borrowers, mortgage owners (including investors), and the courts. 
These provisions will prevent the egregious “robo-signing” practices that were rampant from ever happening again. These obligations apply even through transfers of servicing rights between firms; both the transferor and the transferee have the same duties to maintain accurate information about an account. This cuts off yet another frequent source of harm to consumers.

The Fed knew that opacity was the problem in 2007, why hasn't it championed transparency?

From the Fed transcript of the FOMC meeting on August 7, 2007.  Speaker Bill Dudley, then manager of system open market account:
So how does one explain the contagion to corporate credit from the subprime market given the disparity in fundamentals between these two sectors? 
Although the answer is complex, one factor stands out: There has been a loss of confidence among investors in their ability to assess the value of and risks associated with structured products, which has led to a sharp drop in demand for such products. 
The loss of confidence stems from many sources, including the opacity of such products; the infrequency of trades, which makes it more difficult to judge appropriate valuation; the difficulty in forecasting losses and the correlation of losses in the underlying collateral; the sensitivity of returns to the loss rate and the degree of correlation; and the problem that the credit rating focuses mainly on one risk—that of loss from default.  
Please note that it is the opacity of structured finance markets that makes them impossible for market participants to assess their value and risk.

When investors cannot assess the value and risk of an investment due to a lack of transparency, they stop buying or selling said securities.  They stop because they have no way of independently determining the value of the securities and comparing this independent valuation to the prices shown by Wall Street to make a buy, hold or sell decision.

More than five years after this FOMC meeting, the question is:  what has changed about structured finance securities to make them transparent?

The answer is nothing.

These securities will not be transparent until such time as they provide observable event based reporting and all activities like payments and delinquencies on the underlying collateral are reported before the beginning of the next business day.

Without observable event based reporting, buyers or sellers of these securities are simply blindly betting on the contents of brown paper bags.
The CLO and CDO markets have facilitated the transformation of low-rated paper—for which there is a limited investor appetite—into a high proportion of high-grade-rated debt. 
For example, in a typical CLO structure, the underlying loan quality averages a rating of about B. Yet through the magic of structured finance and the corporate rating agencies, the resulting CLO tranches are rated predominately investment grade. 
Exhibit 8 shows the structure for a representative CLO: More than two-thirds is AAA-rated debt, and 87 percent is investment grade. 
The loss of confidence among investors in the ability to assess the value and risks associated with this structured product has led to a sharp drop in CDO and CLO issuance. 
As shown in exhibit 9, CLO and CDO issuance plummeted in July. 
This is very important because the CLO and CDO markets represent the bulk of the demand for non-investment-grade debt. With this demand falling away at a time when the forward supply of high-yield corporate loans and debt exceeds $300 billion by some measures, a huge mismatch between demand and supply has developed. 
The underlying problem is that the depth of the market for non-investment-grade rated loans and debt—excluding CDO and CLO demand—is far shallower than the market for investment-grade products. 
The only way to restore depth to the market is to provide transparency.  Until this is done, the buyers will remain on strike.

Please note that based on the minutes of the FOMC this simple fact was known prior to the beginning of the financial crisis on August 9, 2007.

Yes, in all of the Fed's responses to the financial crisis, the Fed has never addressed making structured finance securities and bank balance sheets transparent.

Update
From the August 10, 2007 Fed conference call, Ben Bernanke speaking:

President Fisher, our goal is to provide liquidity not to support asset prices per se in any way. 
My understanding of the market’s problem is that price discovery has been inhibited by the illiquidity of the subprime-related assets that are not trading, and nobody knows what they’re worth, and so there’s a general freeze-up. 
The market is not operating in a normal way. The idea of providing liquidity is essentially to give the market some ability to do the appropriate repricing it needs to do and to begin to operate more normally. 
So it’s a question of market functioning, not a question of bailing anybody out. That’s really where we are right now. 
Please re-read the highlighted text as within a span of 3 days following the FOMC meeting that said that opacity was making it impossible for market participants to value structured finance securities, Mr. Bernanke has completely forgotten the problem needs to be addressed.

Note that he asserts that the goal is to provide liquidity until the market's problem with price discovery is fixed.

And lo and behold, the Fed has been adding liquidity through programs like quantitative easing ever since.  Of course there is no end in sight for these liquidity programs because no one is working to make these securities transparent!!! 

Update II
Governor Mishkin on August 16, 2007 conference call discussing letting banks pledge structured finance securities at the discount window as a mechanism for unfreezing the frozen subprime mortgage market caused by the buyers' strike,

The issue is that there’s an information problem in the markets, but the banks’ knowing that there’s a backstop and that we’re doing something in terms of the discount window could actually unfreeze the system so that we could have players come into these mortgage markets to replace the players that are now not in the mortgage markets. 
An information problem that can only be solved by bringing transparency to both structured finance securities and bank balance sheets.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

The Atlantic: What's inside America's banks

The cover story of The Atlantic asks the question:  What's inside America's banks.

Regular readers know that a recurring them on this blog has been to answer this question by requiring the banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

From Barry Ritholtz and the Big Picture:  Big banks are 'black boxes', disclosure is "woeful":
“The banks should give a full, fair, and accurate account of their financial positions and they are failing that test.”
-Kevin Warsh, former Federal Reserve Board member 
“After serving on the [FASB] board, I no longer trust bank accounting.”
-Don Young,  Financial Accounting Standards Board 
“Do I trust Bank Accounting? Absolutely not.”
-Ed Trott, Financial Accounting Standards Board member 
“There is no major financial institution today whose financial statements provide a meaningful clue” about its risks.
-Paul Singer, Elliott Associates

This month’s must read cover story of The Atlantic was written by two of my favorite writers... 
They discuss an issue I have talked about here repeatedly — that banks are essentially opaque black boxes; banks have purposefully concealed what’s on their balance sheets; that they are not merely complex, but actually deceptive; investors have no idea what they are buying when they own one of the behemoth money centers like Citigroup (C), Bank of America (BAC), Wells Fargo (WFC) or JP Morgan (JPM). 
Of course, no bank article would be complete without at least a mention of the bank frauds and illegal actions that are now merely a cost of doing business: Helping Mexican drug dealers launder money (HSBC); funneling cash to Iran (Standard Chartered); LIBOR fraud (Barclays and a cast of dozens); falsifying mortgage records/improperly foreclosing on borrowers (all the giant banks); routinely misleading clients (Merrill, Morgan Stanley, Citi); Selling securities known to be garbage (Goldman Sachs, Merrill); secretly betting against clients to profit from their ignorance (Goldman Sachs). 
Two discussion lines in the article stood out: The first is the number of former bankers now calling for a break up of the giant money center banks: Philip Purcell (ex-CEO of Morgan Stanley Dean Witter), Sallie Krawcheck (ex-CFO of Citigroup), David Komansky (ex-CEO of Merrill Lynch), and John Reed (former co‑CEO of Citigroup). Sandy Weill, another ex-CEO of Citigroup. 
The second is the heart of the article: How opaque, misleading, non-disclosing and — WTF, let’s just say it — fraudulent bank balance sheets are.
Perhaps the most damning quote in the entire column comes from former Federal Reserve Board member Kevin Warsh. He suggested that the financial statements a big bank files with the SEC are worthless: 
“Investors can’t truly understand the nature and quality of the assets and liabilities. They can’t readily assess the reliability of the capital to offset real losses. They can’t assess the underlying sources of the firms’ profits. The disclosure obfuscates more than it informs, and the government is not just permitting it but seems to be encouraging it.” 
That is a damning statement [and should be re-read as it is the reason why ultra transparency is required].
If the first rule of investing is know what you own, than how can anyone credibly own a major money center bank? The answer, at least for me, is that you cannot — owning bank stocks is not investing, it is pure speculation. 
The same can be said about all structured finance securities.
Who wants to make a bet that insiders are going to act in good faith on what is an investor’s best interests?
For this week at least, the focus is now on your humble blogger's topic.

Thursday, December 20, 2012

As shown by Basel Committee, regulators know there is something wrong with securitization, but cannot figure it out

As reported by Reuters, the Basel Committee knows there is something wrong with the reform of structured finance to date and has issued a public consultation that has the sell-side howling in protest.

Regular readers know that what the Basel Committee is troubled by, but hasn't put its finger on yet, is that disclosure has two components:  "what" is disclose and "when" it is disclosed.

Since the beginning of the financial crisis, the sell-side has set the agenda at focusing on "what" is disclosed.  This issue of "when" has been completely pushed off the agenda.

As a result of the sell-side's agenda, reform of structured finance appears incomplete.  The regulators sense that it is incomplete and have basically said, its time to restart the process as if we were at the beginning of the crisis and the financial system was collapsing because of opaque, toxic sub-prime mortgage-backed securities.

The key word is opaque.  That is where disclosure comes in.

The public consultation is also a direct rebuke of the European Data Warehouse and the Prime Collateralise Securities initiative.  Clearly, the regulators sense that neither of these is going to satisfactorily address the issue of opacity.
Market participants warned this week that a new consultation launched by the Basel Committee on securitisation fell into the same traps as previous initiatives. 
Securitisations are backed by a huge variety of different claims, but the framework treats everything presented in securitised format as being part of the same asset class. 
The new paper aims to change the amount of capital banks hold against securitisations, despite the fact that current capital levels were only agreed in 2009 and will be further changed when Basel III is implemented. 
Furthermore, it comes as the Financial Services Board aims to look again at securitisation as part of its shadow banking reforms, a project it only started late last year. 
Market participants warned that there was much technical detail contained in the proposed new framework as well as other potential pitfalls. 
"There is also initial concern that once again policymakers may have fallen into the trap of characterising all securitisations with the poor performance of certain markets during the crisis, namely US subprime and CDOs," said Richard Hopkin, a managing director at the Association for Financial Markets in Europe.
Please note that the Association for Financial Markets in Europe is a sell-side dominated lobbying group.  Therefore, it is not surprising that Mr. Hopkin's statement suggests that all securitizations do no contain common elements.

In fact, all securitization transactions do contain common elements.  They are lemons without adequate investor protections.

Common to all securitization transactions is the lack of the most basic investor protection: disclosure.  Everyone knows that the standard for disclosure is that market participants have access to all the useful, relevant information in an appropriate, timely manner so they can independently assess each security and make a fully informed investment decision.

For structured finance securities to meet this standard of disclosure, they have to provide observable event based reporting.  Under observable event based reporting, all activities like a payment or delinquency involving the underlying collateral are reported to market participants before the beginning of the next business day.

Without observable event based reporting, investors cannot know what they are buying or after buying know what they own.
One senior securitisation lawyer said: "Outside the securitisation framework, SME risk and mortgage risk are treated completely differently, but once you put them in a securitisation, for regulatory purposes, they become the same."...
In the absence of observable event based reporting and other credible investor protections, the argument that the different asset types perform differently is a red herring argument.

By treating all asset types the same, the Basel Committee is effectively saying that in the absence of observable event based reporting and other credible investor protections, banks don't know what they are buying regardless of what type of underlying assets.  As a result, banks need to hold a lot of capital against these blind bets.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Why have the ECB and BoE endorsed a solution that does not bring transparency to structured finance securities?

In attempting to bring transparency to structured finance securities, why have the ECB and BoE endorsed a solution that retains the reporting frequency that makes these securities opaque?

Let's rule out stupidity.  We are dealing with a bunch of PhD economists and a few lawyers.

More likely, we are dealing with regulatory capture.  Not something that you associate with central banks, but that exists none the less.

Reuters carried a fascinating article that helps to answer the question.  The article looks at how the ECB and the BoE used their influence to have the securitization industry build a data warehouse to provide "transparency" into the performance of the underlying collateral.

One way the ECB and BoE used their influence was to bless the data warehouse by saying that any structured finance deal that provides loan-level performance data through this data warehouse qualifies because it is transparent to be pledged as collateral to the central banks.

In addition, the ECB leaned on issuers to fund the project!

What emerged under the influence of the ECB and BoE was the European DataWarehouse.  A data warehouse that will provide loan-level performance data on the same reporting basis as opaque, toxic subprime mortgage-backed securities:  once-per-month.

Regular readers of this blog know that there are two elements to transparency:  what is disclosed and when it is disclosed.

Everyone knows that structured finance securities involve taking specific assets, like mortgages, and setting them aside for the benefit of the investor.  The physical equivalent of this would be to put them into a bag.

Once the mortgages are in the bag, it is important to know what is in the bag currently.

Why?

If an investor does not know what is in the bag currently, they cannot take the first step in the investment cycle.

The first step is to independently assess the risk and value the underlying collateral so the investor can know what the investor is buying and, after buying, know what they own (in the eurozone, please see Article 122a of the European Capital Requirements Directive).

The second step is to compare this independent assessment to the prices shown by Wall Street or the City.

The third and final step is to make a buy, hold or sell decision based on the difference between the investor’s independent valuation of the security and the price shown by Wall Street or the City.

Please note that without the ability to know what is in the bag currently, it is impossible to accurately assess what is going to come out of the bag eventually.

The lack of knowing what is in the bag currently prevents investors from performing their own independent assessment and makes meaningless hiring an expert third party to do the assessment for them.  Simply put, without current information of what is in the bag, investors cannot go through the investment cycle.

Buying securities in the absence of an independent assessment is not investing.   Buying securities that cannot be independently assessed is the equivalent of blindly betting on the contents of a brown paper bag.

In case you doubt this, let me show it to you as I have shown both the ECB and BoE using a brown paper bag to hold the underlying collateral.

On the first business day of last month, $100 went into the bag.  On the third business day of this month, a trustee report with granular level data was issued that showed the bag contained $75 at the end of the last month.  This was made up of 3 $20 bills and 3 $5 bills.

So the question is:  what is in the bag currently?

Based on the fact that $25 came out of the bag last month, there are a number of ways of guessing what is in the brown paper bag?  First, we could guess that nothing has been taken out of the bag and it still holds $75. Or a $5 bill has been removed and left $70 in the bag.  Or a $20 bill has been removed and left $55 in the bag?  Or both a $5 bill and a $20 bill have been removed and left $50 in the bag?

By simply asking what is in the brown paper bag currently, I have already created a $25 spread between the $75 a seller might reasonably value the contents of the brown paper bag at and the $50 a buyer might be willing to offer.

Let me assure you that with this wide a spread, the contents of the brown paper bag are not going to sell even if the performance of the underlying collateral had been reported through a data warehouse as there is no transparency into what is being purchased.

The simple solution to unfreezing the market is to allow investors and sellers to know what they are buying and selling by putting the underlying collateral into what is the physical equivalent of a clear plastic bag.

This can be done by providing observable event based reporting.  Under observable event based reporting, all activities like a payment or default on the underlying collateral are reported before the beginning of the next business day.  This way all market participants know exactly what is happening with the collateral so they can independently assess and value the security.
The European Central Bank's loan-level data initiative for structured finance, which should provide detailed loan data to the whole market through the European DataWarehouse (ED), is ready for action. 
The ED was established to ensure the ECB's loan information - which it needs to monitor ABS collateral used for its repo operations - is easily accessible to the whole market. 
The ED will check data that comes in from issuers, ensuring full compliance with the ECB's standard templates, and provide the IT systems for data providers to hook into its systems. 
The project is supposed to "create a central point (or forum) where industries, associations and national agencies can lodge their data and information in an open, transparent and trusted environment". 
The ECB hopes this will boost private sector demand for securitisation - allowing peripheral banks to replace some of their EUR371.7bn of ABS-backed central bank repo funding with transactions placed with third-parties. 
With that much exposure, the ECB has an incredible incentive to push for the creation of a data warehouse.
Issuers wanting their securitisations issues to be ECB-eligible will have to provide this data to the European DataWarehouse....
This certainly gives the ECB a big lever to force the issuers to provide data and invest in the data warehouse.
The data initiative began in 2009, when regulators became convinced that the securitisation industry needed to improve disclosure on the assets which backed the securities if it was to regain investor trust. Transparency became a major part of the drive to re-regulate securitisation....
Please note, that on April 14 2008, your humble blogger wrote a Total Securitization Learning Curve column that laid out why transparency was needed for structured finance securities and that it should be provided through a data warehouse.

I was invited to write this column, because, from the buy side's perspective, I am the independent global expert on transparency and structured finance securities.
Various senior market participants were invited to help draft templates to present loan level data in standard, comparable format across Europe. Each jurisdiction records different data about borrowers - and different information depending on whether they are borrowing via credit card, mortgage, or unsecured loan. This must be anonymous - but be specific enough to be useful.
This exercise was led by the sell-side through its captured industry trade groups (the European Securitisation Forum and its successor AFME) with the explicit goals of delaying transparency as long as possible and assuring that the data being disclosed would be useless.

They have succeeded.

Based on my conversation with several valuation firms that work strictly for the buy side, the data fields that will be disclosed don't allow them to run some of their key analyzes.
Following production of the templates, the ECB decided to encourage the construction of a whole new piece of market infrastructure to provide this data.
One might wonder why the ECB which knew of my existence and the fact that my firm had already designed and held a patent on this new piece of market infrastructure did not talk to me.

Based on the my responses to its public consultation, it was clear to the ECB that my solution was biased to the buy-side.

Instead,
Paul Burdell of Link Financial, acting as an adviser to the ECB at this time, took on the project, soon dubbed the European DataWarehouse.
Eight institutions drawn from the technical working groups managed the procurement process, picking Sapient Global Markets as constructor.
As I said, regulatory capture?
The ECB maintained an arms-length distance from the project, aiming to present the European DataWarehouse as a market-driven exercise.
Clearly, the ECB did not have an arms-length distance from the project.  It endorsed the European DataWarehouse when there was already a viable solution, my firm's data warehouse, in the market.
Speaking on Thursday in Frankfurt, Peter Praet, chief economist at the ECB, described loan-level data as a classic collective action problem - no individual issuer had an incentive to start making this data available, but official sector organisations could act as catalysts to improve market practice. 
The central bank retained an observer role, since it anticipated being a major user of the resulting data - indeed, it is the only institution so far to have trialled access to the data.
A data warehouse would have been built and made available simply by the ECB and BoE making loan-level data a requirement for eligibility.

It would have been economically attractive to build this data warehouse as there are almost 400 billion euros on the ECB balance sheet that would have needed a data warehouse had the ECB and BoE stuck to making loan-level disclosure an eligibility requirement.

However, the ECB and the BoE did not stop with this simple requirement.  They wanted to choose a winner.  And in choosing a winner they managed to chose a solution that is designed to protect opacity in the structured finance market.
No third party investors in ABS have yet approached the ED about using the data. 
Which shows that these investors are listening to your humble blogger as the data is worthless because it is out of date and does not answer the question of what is in the bag currently.

Investors know that structured finance securities are lemons unless there is observable event based reporting so there is no reason to "pay" for useless data.

Investors also know that under Reg FD (fair disclosure), the information must be disclosed for free to US investors.  Again, no reason to pay.

Finally, money managers know that in the absence of observable event based reporting by ED they have to disclose to their investors that they are blindly betting on the contents of a brown paper bag if they use the data from ED.  Without this disclosure, the money managers and their firms are liable for any losses on investments in these securities.

Of course, this disclosure would also make it impossible for the money managers to buy these securities with ED reporting as investors are not going to give their money to someone to blindly bet on the contents of a brown paper bag.
The project has proved controversial, particularly with some of the large UK issuers, because while the ECB was the main driver of the project, the central bank refused to pay for it, arguing that the industry needed to show willing. 
Again, the central bank didn't need to pay for it.  They simply had to make transparency a criteria for eligibility.  Transparency that addresses both what is disclose and when it is disclosed in a way that places the underlying collateral in the equivalent of a clear plastic bag.
Instead of being a public utility, ED is a profit-making private sector company, paid for by a private share placement to market participants, managed by Perella Weinberg. 
Shareholders get a discount on submitting their data. The idea was a co-operative system, analogous to SWIFT, the payments communication standard owned by its member banks. 
Loading loan-level data into the DataWarehouse is necessary to make ABS central bank eligible, but can only be achieved by paying ED a fee. One senior figure close to the project described it as a toll-booth on the only route to a destination. However, the profit rate is to be limited to 10% and is to be used for reinvestment.
And here we get to the real reason that the sell-side pushed the ECB into promoting the European DataWarehouse.  My firm would have owned the data warehouse and charged a toll.

This way, the sell-side can both minimize the toll and make some money off of the toll.
Initial target funding was EUR20m, though this was subsequently revised to EUR11m. Fundraising for this smaller amount was completed by July 2012, but 15 other institutions have publically committed funds so far, with Dutch institutions also involved, despite reports to the contrary. 
The shareholder list, available on the ED website, is heavily skewed towards peripheral institutions. 
Some firms were initially reluctant to offer financial backing to the project - Executive Board members of the ECB had to use their contacts with senior bank management to encourage them to buy shares. 
Despite this encouragement, some issuer communities decided to only invest under the guise of existing market associations - German banks under the banner of True Sale International and Dutch banks through the newly minted Dutch Securitisation Association.
So much for arms-length or just being an observer.  When a central bank uses their contacts to encourage bank management to buy shares, they have step directly into endorsement mode.

An endorsement that subjects both the ECB and the BoE to public examination.  

When the European DataWarehouse fails to reopen the market for structured finance securities in the first quarter of 2013, Mr. Draghi, the head of the ECB, and Sir Mervyn King, the governor of the BoE, should be held responsible for explaining why they endorsed blindly betting on the contents of a brown paper bag.

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Turning lemon mortgage-backed securities to lemonade


The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) recently called for  requiring disclosure so that investors can independently assess the creditworthiness of the underlying collateral for each structured finance product.

Let me show you how correctly implementing this simple requirement would turn lemon mortgage-backed securities into lemonade.

Disclosure has two components:  what is disclosed and when it is disclosed.  I would like to focus on “when” it is disclosed.

Everyone knows that structured finance securities involve taking specific assets, like mortgages, and setting them aside for the benefit of the investor.  The physical equivalent of this would be to put them into a bag.

Once the mortgages are in the bag, it is important to know what is in the bag currently. 

Why?

If an investor does not know what is in the bag currently, they cannot take the first step in the investment cycle. 

The first step is to independently assess the risk and value the underlying collateral so the investor can know what the investor is buying and, after buying, know what they own.

The second step is to compare this independent assessment to the prices shown by Wall Street.

The third and final step is to make a buy, hold or sell decision based on the difference between the investor’s independent valuation of the security and the price shown by Wall Street.

Please note that without the ability to know what is in the bag currently, it is impossible to accurately assess what is going to come out of the bag eventually. 

The lack of knowing what is in the bag currently prevents investors from performing their own independent assessment and makes meaningless hiring an expert third party to do the assessment for them. 

Simply put, without current information of what is in the bag, investors cannot go through the investment cycle.

Buying securities in the absence of an independent assessment is not investing.  Buying securities that cannot be independently assessed is the equivalent of blindly betting on the contents of a brown paper bag.  And, once the securities are purchased, the investor has no ability to know what they own.

In case you doubt this, let me show it to you using a brown paper bag to hold the underlying collateral.

On the first business day of last month, $100 went into the bag.  On the third business day of this month, a trustee report with granular level data was issued that showed the bag contained $75 at the end of the last month.  This was made up of 3 $20 bills and 3 $5 bills.

So the question is:  what is in the bag currently?

Based on the fact that $25 came out of the bag last month, there are a number of ways of guessing what is in the brown paper bag?

First, we could guess that nothing has been taken out of the bag and it still holds $75. Or a $5 bill has been removed and left $70 in the bag.  Or a $20 bill has been removed and left $55 in the bag?  Or both a $5 bill and a $20 bill have been removed and left $50 in the bag?

By simply asking what is in the brown paper bag currently, I have already created a $25 spread between the $75 a seller might reasonably value the contents of the brown paper bag at and the $50 a buyer might be willing to offer.

Let me assure you that with this wide a spread, the contents of the brown paper bag are not going to sell.

This valuation problem has been shown to be particularly acute for mortgage-backed securities since the beginning of the financial crisis.  At that time, buyers came to doubt the ability of the borrowers to make their future payments.  

The more doubt, the more likely the market is to freeze as it is impossible to get buyers, who think that the bag is more likely to have $50, and sellers, who look at last month's performance and think the bag has $75, to agree on price.

Another way we can approach asking what is currently in this brown paper bag is to use a sophisticated model.  We recognize that last month $25 came out of the bag.  This is roughly $0.85 per day.  

So we can value the contents of the brown paper bag by multiplying the day of the month it is today by .85 and subtracting the resulting value from the end of the month value shown in the last trustee report.

Today is the 6th, so the model suggests a value of $69.90 ($75 minus $5.10).  The price suggested by the model doesn't seem unreasonable if a $5 bill is removed from the bag.  

However, a buyer is significantly overpaying if there has been a sharper decline in the value of collateral in the bag and a $20 bill has been removed.  This is analogous to what happened with sub-prime mortgage-backed securities where there was a rapid decline in the value of the collateral.

This problem of guessing what is in the bag would go away if we were talking about a clear plastic bag.  The investor would know what is in the bag currently as the contents of the bag can be seen and are a knowable fact.

As a result, investors could independently assess the risk and value the collateral.  With this assessment, the investor “knows what they are buying” and "knows what they own". 

With this assessment, the investor can make an investment decision to buy, hold or sell based on the prices being shown by Wall Street.

So turning the mortgage market from lemons to lemonade simply requires recognizing that it is a choice between “Paper or Plastic”.  With “Paper”, you get lemons.  With “Plastic”, you get lemonade.

So how can each of the structured finance securities be put into the equivalent of a clear plastic bag?

This can be easily done as the servicer information systems are designed to track and report on the underlying collateral on an observable event basis.

With observable event based disclosure where all activities like a payment or delinquency involving the underlying collateral are reported before the beginning of the next business day, the investor knows what is in the bag currently.

Observable event based disclosure is associated with a clear plastic bag.  All other frequencies of disclosure are associated with a brown paper bag and lemons.