Monday, August 20, 2012

US Treasury moves to wind down Fannie and Freddie

The Wall Street Journal reports that the US Treasury has modified the terms of its receivership of Fannie and Freddie so that it receives all the earnings generated by the GSEs.  The Treasury also increased the speed at which Fannie and Freddie will shrink their portfolios.

All of which raises the interesting question of 'what will replace them?'

Regular readers know that your humble blogger thinks that the replacement for Fannie and Freddie should be based on observable event based reporting.  It is only when all activity like a payment or default on the underlying collateral is reported before the beginning of the next business day that investors have access to the current information they need for monitoring and valuing securities backed by mortgage loans.
The Treasury Department on Friday revamped its financial support of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to accelerate the pace at which the mortgage-finance giants will pay back the government for its rescue four years ago. 
In the latest change to a nearly four-year-old rescue, the Treasury Department will capture all the profits that they post in any given quarter, rather than requiring a 10% annual dividend payment. 
They won't require payments in periods when the firms lose money, ending a perverse cycle where Fannie and Freddie were borrowing from the government simply to make quarterly repayments. 
Administration officials described the move as a way to ensure that the two firms aren't revived as private companies. 
Michael Stegman, a senior Treasury adviser, called the move "the next step toward responsibly winding down" the two mortgage-finance firms.

Sunday, August 19, 2012

Spain setting up state owned bad bank to hold non-performing loans

Taking a failed strategy from the Irish playbook, Spain is setting up a state owned bad bank to hold the non-performing assets in its banking system.

Regular readers know that bad banks fail for a number of reasons.

  • What qualifies as a non-performing asset?  Remember, a sizable percentage of the real estate related loans on the Spanish bank balance sheets are in 'extend and pretend' mode.  Are these going to be realized as non-performing?
  • What price does the bad bank pay for the assets?  If the bad bank overpays for the assets, then the Spanish taxpayer incurs far higher losses than necessary.
  • How does anyone know that all of the bad assets have been removed from the Spanish banking system?  It is this question that renders the entire exercise futile.  Are market participants going to trust the Spanish authorities who have repeatedly said there is no problem only to have a major problem emerge?  Ultimately, the only way to assure that all the assets have been removed is to require the banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose their current exposure details.  
According to a Bloomberg article,
Spain will put its bank rescue fund in charge of the bad assets separated out from the nation’s struggling lenders that are receiving a European bailout. 
The FROB fund will be the main shareholder in a so-called bad bank, according to a proposal that will be approved by the Cabinet on Aug. 24, Economy Minister Luis de Guindos told the Efe news agency in an interview today. 
All the banks receiving loans from European rescue funds will have to transfer their non-performing assets to the bad bank, he said. The comments were confirmed by a Spanish official, who asked not be identified, citing government policy.

Bank of England issued warning last year that UK banking system could collapse

The Telegraph reports that before last Christmas the Bank of England's Paul Tucker warned the heads of the largest UK banks that their businesses would not survive a collapse of the eurozone.

What has changed since then?

Have the banks completely sold off all of their exposure to the EU?  Have the banks raised so much capital that they could absorb the losses on the EU exposures?

At a minimum, this confirms the needs for ultra transparency and the creation of the "Mother of all financial databases" so these questions can be answered by all market participants.

Bank of England officials were so concerned about the potential for a financial crisis late last year they took the extra­ordinary step of warning the entire banking system could collapse “before Christmas”. 
Paul Tucker, the deputy governor of the Bank of England, told an October meeting of the chief executives of Britain’s largest banks that there was a serious chance none of their businesses would survive to the end of the year. 
“Gentlemen, you could all be out of business by Christmas,” Mr Tucker said in a stark warning to the bank chiefs, according to three sources present at the meeting. 
The revelation of Mr Tucker’s remarkable warning shows the depth of fear among senior officials over the havoc the collapse of the eurozone would wreak on the British financial system.... 
Minutes published by the Bank’s Financial Policy Committee in September and December made clear the depth of its concerns, but the explicit warning given to the chief executives shows that officials feared a crisis even greater than that in the wake of the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008. 
The meeting led directly to the creation of working groups at banks to gauge the potential for a full-scale collapse of the financial system. 
One executive present said his institution had been so concerned by Mr Tucker’s warning that it had re-evaluated its entire risk positions. 
It is shocking to think that the banks late last year had no idea their exposure to an EU collapse.

This is further confirmation of the need to require the banks to disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details.

With this data, everyone would know everyone else's exposure.
However, another executive present said he had been disappointed with the Bank of England’s response and said that, despite the dire warning, it actually did “very little” to help deal with the situation. 
The most important aspect of transparency is that it puts each market participant into a position where they can do something to help deal with the situation.  They can take action based on facts and not fear.

Finally, there is a need for financial regulators to distinguish between bankers who will not be there if losses occur and banking institutions that will not be there.

As regular readers know, banks are designed to continue to operate even when they have negative book capital levels due to the combination of deposit insurance and access to central bank funding.  While they are rebuilding their book capital through retention of 100% of pre-banker bonus earnings, the taxpayers are the bank's 'silent' equity partner.

However, there is no reason that the bankers responsible for losing the bank's book capital should continue to be employed.

Saturday, August 18, 2012

Parliament Libor Report: Both Banks and Regulators need to change

Parliament's Treasury Select Committee led by Andrew Tyrie issued a report on the Libor rigging scandal in which it concluded:
Among its wide-ranging conclusions were that Barclays operated for years with woefully inadequate controls, that senior staff at the bank should have taken action earlier, that the Financial Services Authority (FSA) failed in its duty as regulator to respond to rumours of rate-fixing, and that the Bank of England had been “naive” and “inactive”. 
“Public trust in banks is at an all-time low,” Andrew Tyrie, chairman of the TSC, said. “Urgent improvements, both to the way banks are run and the way they are regulated, is needed if public and market confidence is to be restored.”
This conclusion applies not just to UK regulators, but to EU and US regulators too.

In his Telegraph column, Damian Reece discusses the implications of Parliament's conclusion:

But what we’re also left with, yet again, is a story of regulatory failure. Since 1997 the UK has been plagued by porous rules that have allowed unalloyed avarice to seep into every nook and cranny of City life. 
It is Tyrie’s conclusions and recommendations in this area which are the most important elements of the report. 
The committee has quite rightly used its findings into the Libor scandal as ammunition in its attempts to get urgent changes made to the legislation passing through Parliament that will merge two failing institutions (the Financial Services Authority and the Bank of England) into one, even larger, failing institution. If we don’t get the future of regulation right, we’ll never get the future of banking right.
Please re-read the highlighted text as Mr. Reece has elegantly made the case for why we need to bring transparency back of every opaque corner of the financial system and create the 'Mother of All Financial Databases".  Everyone knows that sunlight is best disinfectant.

By requiring banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details, bank behavior can be changed and avarice held in check.

The regulators failed in the lead up to the financial crisis.  Libor is simply another example of their failure.

The only way to get the future of regulation right is not to let the regulators operate behind a veil of opacity. There is no reason to put the financial system at risk of failing again because the financial regulators fail once again to accurately assess the risk in the banks and the rest of the financial system.

Transparency reduces, if not eliminates, the financial markets dependence on the regulators as market participants can assess the data for themselves and adjust the amount and price of their exposures accordingly.
Tyrie’s report does highlight how the FSA, led by chairman Lord Turner, has shown glimpses of the so called “judgment-led” regulation that will be the founding principle of the new regime. 
Judgment-led regulation is the notion of regulators standing toe to toe with bank chiefs and telling them when they don’t like what they see on their balance sheets and informing them what needs to change. It’s about telling a board that changes need making to key personnel. The banks will hate it but that’s exactly the point. The quid pro quo is that at least some of the petty box ticking will be abolished that drives bankers wild and probably encourages, rather than discourages, the culture of pushing regulatory boundaries to the limit. 
Here is a classic example of the Financial-Academic-Regulatory Complex (FARC) trying to protect itself and expand its power.

A problem the financial crisis exposed is that regulators are not a reliable substitute for the market in enforcing discipline on banks.  Yet, judgment-led regulation is based on the notion of the regulators going toe-to-toe with the banks.

How dumb is that?

To enforce discipline, the regulators first have to be able to assess what is going on at the banks.  Without ultra transparency, the regulators are substituting their analytical ability for the markets' analytical ability.

It is well known that the market does a better job of analysis as it has much more in the way of resources (financial and expertise) as well as an incentive to do a better job than the banks.

To enforce discipline, the regulators then have to go toe-to-toe with bank executives. This is regulators substituting their machismo for the market.

Given the recent Standard Chartered money laundering scandal, we can see that the regulators are going to back down.  If engaging in $250 billion of money laundering with Iran after entering an agreement to prevent this practice is not enough to lose a banking license, bankers have nothing to fear from regulators other than a fine which is an insignificant cost of doing business.

Markets are much bigger than the banks and much more capable of meting out discipline than regulators.  This discipline takes the form of reducing bank stock prices and access to funds to reflect the performance of the bank.
But Tyrie’s report also reveals how Lord Turner and his counterpart at the Bank of England, Sir Mervyn King, were unable to exercise that judgment-based regulation properly when it came to the removal of Bob Diamond. They wielded the axe in an arbitrary way which was inappropriate and which cannot be tolerated. 
The fact that Lord Turner tried and failed to secure Diamond’s resignation and subsequently had to get Sir Mervyn involved also exposes him as a weak operator. Put this together with the fact that the FSA, along with the Bank, failed to spot Libor manipulation in the first place and that “doesn’t look good” to quote Tyrie once again. It doesn’t look good for the FSA but neither does it look good for Lord Turner’s candidacy to be the next Governor of the Bank of England, with supreme power over all financial regulation. 
So what have we learnt? We’ve learnt that the old guard has had its day. It’s changing at the banks but now it must change at the regulators too.

Thursday, August 16, 2012

Paul Singer urges Romney shift on bank regulation

Showing that requiring banks to provide ultra transparency has bipartisan support, hedge fund manager Paul Singer has urged Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney to pursue it.

According to a Financial Times article,

Paul Singer, the billionaire hedge fund manager who is one of the Republican party’s most influential donors, is pressing Mitt Romney, presidential candidate, to make the case for tougher bank regulation that would go beyond the Dodd-Frank law. 
Mr Singer, the chairman of Elliott Associates, recently sent copies of his quarterly investor letter to Romney officials, laying out the need for tighter regulation. The letter, which he distributes to investors and policy makers across the political spectrum, says Dodd-Frank is “ill-conceived” and could cause a financial “black hole”. 
In place of Dodd-Frank Mr Singer wants ... a regulatory framework that forces big banks to be more transparent about liabilities and off-balance sheet instruments.  
“Conservatives who believe in free markets should also believe in sound fair markets,” Mr Singer told the FT. 
“Private reward and public risk is not what conservatives should want.”
While the idea of transparency was initially enshrined in our financial system by the FDR Administration, Mr. Singer shows that it has support across the political spectrum.

Of course, the banks and the rest of the Financial-Academic-Regulatory Complex (FARC) will fight against Mr. Singer and his call for transparency as it would eliminate the profits banks make from opacity and reduce the power and influence of the regulators.

As noted in the FT article,

“It is the big highly leveraged financial institutions which are opaque and were instrumental in the financial collapse,” Mr Singer told the FT. 
“They will likely lobby against the fixes that I believe are necessary. But the fixes are essential. If they do not occur, the next financial crisis could be similar to the last one, but perhaps more sudden and intense.” 
Please re-read the highlighted text as it nicely summarizes what your humble blogger has been saying since the beginning of the financial crisis.
The Romney campaign said in a statement that the current regulatory system was “poorly equipped to deal with dynamic and evolving markets”. 
It said Mr Romney would “implement a sensible, streamlined regulatory framework that doesn’t overly burden small banks or hurt small businesses. This regulation will include enhanced capital requirements and greater transparency for our financial institutions”.
One of the great strengths of requiring banks to provide ultra transparency and disclose on an ongoing basis their current global asset, liability and off-balance sheet exposure details is that it reduces the need for regulation.

For example, as I have talked about before, ultra transparency enforces the Volcker Rule without the need for hundreds of pages of regulations.

Given what the Republican party says about a desire for smaller government and supporting sound, fair, free markets, ultra transparency would seem like a natural for Republicans to support.

However, it is a testament to how the financial institutions contribute to politicians that not a single Republican has come out publicly in favor of ultra transparency.  Instead, they continue to protect the opacity on Wall Street that Mr. Singer says lead to the financial crisis.

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

After a lost half decade, how Japanese are we?

In his Wall Street Journal blog, Matt Phillips looks at the performance of the US economy since the beginning of the financial crisis and compares it to Japan's in the early years after its financial crisis.

He finds that regardless of when central banks adopted zero interest rate policies there is still no economic growth, let alone a recovery.

Regular readers are not surprised by this finding as central bankers using monetary policy do not have the tools  to deal with a bank solvency led financial crisis.

The simple, straight forward and only proven way to deal with a bank solvency led financial crisis is to require banks to recognize all the losses hidden on and off their balance sheets today.  By making banks absorb the losses on the excess debt in the financial system, the banks protect the real economy and society.

In a modern banking system with deposit guarantees and access to central bank funding, banks can operate for years and support the real economy while rebuilding their book capital levels.  During this time, the deposit guarantee effectively makes the taxpayers the banks' silent equity partner.

Your humble blogger refers to this as the Swedish model and it has been successful whenever and where ever it has been implemented.  This includes the US to break the back of the Great Depression, Sweden and Iceland.

By comparison, the US (EU and UK too) and Japan have chosen a model that protects bank book capital levels at all costs.  This puts the burden of servicing the excess debt in the financial system squarely on the real economy and society.  A burden that shifts resources from economic growth and social programs to debt service.

It is no surprise that this model, which I refer to as the Japanese model, doesn't work.  The only beneficiaries from pursuing this model are the bankers.

Having said that, it is still not too late for policy makers to require the banks to absorb the losses on the excesses in the financial system and to bring to an end the downward spiral in the real economy.

Unfortunately, neither the Republicans or the Democrats is talking about having the banks absorb the losses and protect society.  Instead, both are talking about how they would cut the social programs for the benefit of banker bonuses.

Standard Chartered money laundering scandal shows degree global regulators captured by banks

As the dust settles on Standard Chartered's settlement with the New York's Department of Financial Services, a bright light remains on the global financial regulators and the degree to which they are captured by the banks.

Neil Barofsky summarized for Bloomberg exactly what transpired.
I can’t think of another case where there has been such uniformity among federal regulators undercutting an enforcement case.
Included in the list of global financial regulators undercutting the enforcement case was the Bank of England and the UK's Chancellor as well as the Federal Reserve and the Treasury.

The two who are most troubling that are on the list are the BoE and the Fed.  Their involvement raises the simple question of "why should anyone believe they are going to enforce bank regulations and the law?"

The answer to this question is important because as a result of the financial crisis both the BoE and the Fed have been given extensive new powers in the area of enforcing bank regulations and the law.

Unfortunately, between their past history leading up to the financial crisis and their recent conduct, there is no reason to believe that the BoE or the Fed is capable of actually taking action and meaningfully enforcing bank regulations and the law.

I used the term meaningfully on purpose.

Money laundering by a bank is optional.  There is no mystery what banks have to do to avoid money laundering.  Since there is no mystery, it should never occur (yes, I will accept that on an extremely rare occasion a mistake will be made).

In the case of Standard Chartered, we are not talking extremely rare as there were at least 300 transactions out of 60,000 that it acknowledges were problematic.  In addition, senior management went to great lengths to hide what was going on from regulators.

The fines that Standard Chartered is paying for laundering up to $250 billion for Iran are not meaningful.  Stripping Standard Chartered of its New York banking license would have been meaningful.

However, could you imagine a state regulator having the courage to take such a step while they are being systematically undercut by the Washington-based regulatory complex - the Treasury and the Federal Reserve - who don't want a big bank meaningfully punished.

In effect, we have a race to the bottom among regulators.  A race that effectively destroys confidence in the capital markets and the capital markets themselves.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Oil and gas fracking disclosures show why transparency cannot be left to industry or its trade groups

Bloomberg carried an article on disclosure of fracking wells by oil and gas firms that illustrates why transparency cannot be left to companies in the industry or their trade groups.

What the oil and gas industry has done parallels what has occurred in the financial sector with banks and structured finance securities.

Seeking to quell environmental concerns about the chemicals it shoots underground to extract oil and natural gas, Apache Corp. (APA) told shareholders in April that it disclosed information about “all the company’s U.S. hydraulic fracturing jobs” on a website last year. 
Actually, Apache’s transparency was shot through with cracks. 
In Texas and Oklahoma, the company reported chemicals it used on only about half its fracked wells via FracFocus.org, a voluntary website that oil and gas companies helped design amid calls for mandatory disclosure. 
Energy companies failed to list more than two out of every five fracked wells in eight U.S. states from April 11, 2011, when FracFocus began operating, through the end of last year, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. 
The gaps reveal shortcomings in the voluntary approach to transparency on the site, which has received funding from oil and gas trade groups and $1.5 million from the U.S. Department of Energy.
“FracFocus is just a fig leaf for the industry to be able to say they’re doing something in terms of disclosure,” said U.S. Representative Diana DeGette, a Colorado Democrat. DeGette, along with Pennsylvania Senator Robert Casey, introduced legislation in March 2011 that would require companies to disclose fracking chemicals. The bills haven’t advanced in either the House or Senate. 
With FracFocus, “companies that want to disclose can do it but the other ones don’t have to,” DeGette said.
 Kind of like Libor.
Bloomberg compared oil and gas well records from eight states -- Arkansas, Colorado, Louisiana, Montana, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah and Wyoming -- against disclosures that companies made for those states on FracFocus. While the state data didn’t reveal whether wells were fractured, regulators in each state said that at least 85 percent of their wells were fracked. The Congressional Research Service puts the national estimate at more than 90 percent. 
In the eight states, companies told regulators that 18,158 wells were readied for production or were newly producing from April 11, 2011 through Dec. 31, 2011. They disclosed 8,555 of them on FracFocus. If 85 percent of the total wells were fracked, that means 45 percent of the fracks weren’t disclosed on the website. 
Bloomberg’s analysis, covering states that accounted for 64 percent of U.S. gas production in 2010, shows the difficulty of getting a full picture of the industry’s transparency....
That difficulty is intentional as the industry doesn't want transparency.
Oil and gas companies have gotten better at listing their fractured wells on the website over time, said Dan Whitten, a spokesman for America’s Natural Gas Alliance, one of two industry groups that help pay operational costs for the website. Some states now require companies to make disclosures on FracFocus, he said. 
“ANGA operators are committed to transparency, and support public disclosure of the additives used in the hydraulic fracturing process,” Whitten said in an e-mail. “If you were to look at a complete timeframe of FracFocus, you would see a progressively higher rate of participation.”
Sounds a lot like the British Bankers' Association describing Libor.
Companies participating in the voluntary system agree to disclose information about wells on the website once they have been fractured, which is the start of the completion process. ....
At the same time, concerns center on the hundreds of chemicals -- including known carcinogens -- used in the process.
Homeowners in Pennsylvania, Texas and Wyoming have complained that their well water was contaminated with chemicals or methane gas from nearby frack jobs. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency last year linked the method to contaminated drinking water in Pavillion, Wyoming; the agency is now retesting some of those findings. The EPA has little authority to regulate fracking; Congress in 2005 stripped it of most such power....
Is there a parallel here to toxic mortgage-backed securities?
Oil and gas executives say the FracFocus website helps eliminate the need for any new federal oversight that might unify the regulatory approach.

“Rome wasn’t built in a day,” said Cal Cooper, manager of special projects for Apache. “This is a positive thing. It shows industry can get its act together and make things happen in a short amount of time.”....
Bringing transparency to the $15 trillion in structured finance securities could be accomplished in 18 months.  Seems like that is a much bigger IT effort than tracking oil and gas wells.

Sir Richard Branson is latest supporter of 'full transparency' for banks

The Telegraph reports that Sir Richard Branson is the latest supporter of 'full transparency' for banks.

“Banks? Where we’re going, we don’t need banks.” That’s how Christopher Lloyd’s famous line from the end of the first Back to the Future film runs in Simon Dixon’s head. 
The former investment banker is launching Bank to the Future (BTTF), the world’s first “peer-to-peer” market to allow businesses to raise debt, equity or donations from consumers and investors in one place....

The business has caught the attention of Sir Richard Branson, who shortlisted it in his “Screw Business as Usual” competition to find innovative business models.
 
Mr Dixon, who campaigned for reform of the banking sector prior to setting up the company, claims that high street banks are gradually exiting the small business lending market. 
“Other things are more profitable for them — they’re not really interested in small businesses. Banks would rather lend on credit cards secured by income or property rather than lending to limited liability businesses. 
“We don’t think they’ll want to be in this market.”...

Mr Dixon wants BTTF to be a precursor to a full “entrepreneurs’ bank” that could take deposits and allow business owners to invest in a portfolio of other companies of their choosing.
 
“What we want to do is create a fully transparent financial institution where everyone can see what’s happened with their money, so business people can support business people,” he said. 
Sir Richard said: “With recent scandals tarnishing the banking sector once again, there’s a real opportunity for positive change in the industry. 
“I like the goals of BTTF, where everything is transparent and people can see what happens with their money.”

According to Deutsche Bank, central bank policies cost investors $163 billion

Bloomberg reports that according to analysts at Deutsche Bank central bank policies like zero interest rates and quantitative easing are costing investors $163 billion per decade.

In reality, the cost is closer to $100 billion per year.

Global central bank policy that has driven down interest rates to boost economic growth will cost investors about $163 billion over a 10-year period, according to Deutsche Bank AG. 
Yields on government debt have fallen about 81 basis points since the third quarter of 2010 amid $1.74 trillion of debt issuance as central banks expanded their balance sheets, Dominic Konstam, global head of interest-rates research at Deutsche Bank in New York, wrote Aug. 10 in a research report. 
“It seems to be taken for granted now that central bank policies have implicitly underwritten a period of financial repression by artificially suppressing returns,” Deutsche Bank said. “For the issuer this is the mirror image of the benefit in terms of lower borrowing costs.”
Like all analyzes, this one is driven by its assumptions.  In this case, the analysis looked at the decline in interest rates since the third quarter of 2010.  However, by then, central banks were already artificially suppressing interest rates.

If we go back to Treasury rates at the start of the financial crisis during August 2007, the decline in interest rates is much larger.  According to Treasury Direct, the average interest rate on total marketable treasury debt was 4.946%.  This compares to 2.130% in July 2012.  A decline of 2.836% or 3 times as much as used in the Deutsche Bank analysis.

But even this understates the decline as Treasury Direct assumes in calculating its average interest rate that an equal dollar volume of Treasury Bills, Notes and Bonds is issued.  In reality, far more Bills than Bonds are issued.  The decline was 4.735% for Treasury Bills (2012 July Treasury Bills 0.124%; 2007 August Treasury Bills 4.859%) or almost 6 times as much as used in the Deutsche Bank analysis.

Said another way, the direct cost to savers of central banks artificially suppressing interest rates is almost $100 billion per year.

But that is not the only cost.  By definition, savers save.  These are the individuals who are most likely to make up the loss in earnings on their savings by saving more.  To offset the loss in income on their savings, these individuals need to cut back on their consumption by $100 billion.

This $100 billion decrease in consumption represents a headwind to growth in the real economy.